[Wikipedia-l] nn (Norw. Nynorsk) wikipedia
utne at nvg.org
Sat Sep 11 09:11:24 UTC 2004
In Wikipedia-l Digest, Vol 14, Issue 5, brion vibber wrote:
>There's a bug in the new wiki creation script which allows zh-tw, zh-cn,
>nn, and perhaps other language codes which are defined but had been
>intended as aliases to be automatically created as separate wikis. Such
>accidentally created wikis are not supported and may get closed down
>when noticed and someone gets around to backing up their content.
Tim Starling replied:
>I've altered it now so that languages have to be listed in both langlist
>and languages/Names.php before they can be created. So this sort of
>thing shouldn't happen anymore.
I see that nn (Nynorsk) is on your list of undesired entities.
Nynorsk is *an official written language* (not dialect) of Norway
beside the separate written language Bokmål (nb or bm).
Please note the following factors:
* Nynorsk and Bokmål are not "merely one language in different
alphabets" (such as can be argued for Chinese trad. / simplified,
Serbian / Croatian/Bosnian or Hindi / Urdu),
* They are not merely a slight orthographic variation
of one language within different political entities
(such as UK/US English and European/Brazilian Portuguese).
* They have a significant number of different basic terms,
as well as significant differences in orthography,
morphology and syntax.
* The current no.wikipedia is predominantly Bokmål,
with only a small minority of the articles being written in Nynorsk
* There are only three registered Nynorsk users on bm.wikipedia,
and there is consensus amongst these three (see below) that the
development of nn.wikipedia should be worked on now -- partially
because of the greater ease in finding Nynorsk writers for a Nynorsk
wikipedia than for a Bokmål wikpedia with occasional Nynorsk articles.
We also believe as a group (on nn.wikipedia) that Nynorsk writers
joining the project will join the no.wikipedia project as well --
thus hoping to strengthen the Norwegian wikipedia project as a whole.
* The participation in more than one wikipedia project is the norm rather
than the exception amongst Scandinavian "wikipedians" in general.
I participate actively on nn, no/bm, sv and en.
* Our "slogan" on the nn.wikipedia.org main page is:
"Samhald gjev styrke og mangfald gjev rikdom!"
This translates, with as:
"Samhold gir styrke og mangfold gir rikdom!" (Bokmål)
"Sammenhold giver styrke og mangfold giver rigdom!" (Danish)
"Gemenskap ger styrka och mångfall ger rikedom!" (Swedish)
(In English, roughly:)
"Cooperation gives strength and diversity gives wealth!"
I cannot see that there is any reason to block Nynorsk as a separate
wikipedia any more than it would make sense to block Bokmål, Swedish or
Danish as separate entities. Nynorsk is not any less defined as a language
than the three other ones -- and all four of them are mostly mutually
intelligible, by the way.
Why is a Nynorsk wikipedia any more undesirable than an Elsässisch or
Walon one? Or separate Portuguese/Gallego ones? Because some Bokmål users
(officially a different language) are sceptical? Would it be right if
Castilian wikipedians were free to deny a Catalonian wikipedia?
I support fully the advent of a common Scandinavian wikipedia with
user-selected language interface and articles coordinated between the four
official languages (and with parallel articles being useful in many cases)
-- WHEN the time is ready. But I also think it would be wrong to
specifically inhibit the Nynorsk language's opportunity to participate
fully and systematically in the building of material for a joined project
on equal terms, rather than to be forced into the mainly Bokmål project as
a not very visible or transparently organised minority.
Please refer to the page http://nn.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Olve for
the discussion and consensus amongst the Nynorsk users at this early stage.
Our plans are to continue the development of http://nn.wikipedia.org/ and
to start recruiting new users actively when the user interface is more
complete and there are a few more articles. We also have made it very clear
in our discussion that we will strongly encourage these new writers to
participate on http://no.wikipedia.org/ as well -- thus making sure that
our project results in added diversity (through a Nynorsk wikipedia being
made available) as well as a general strengthening of the no,wikipedia project.
Rather than having non-users of the language Nynorsk closing down this one
out of the four separate Scandinavian written languages' wikipedias, it
would be constructive if we could have some assistance in uploading the
finished and available LanguageNn.php file and have one or more of the
Nynorsk writers (currently: Olve, Dittaeva, BjarteSorensen) be appointed as
Any constructive dialogue and/or assistance is of course welcome!
Beste helsing (Best greetings),
More information about the Wikipedia-l