[Wikipedia-l] A different tables approach

Jens Frank JeLuF at gmx.de
Sat Aug 3 14:03:25 UTC 2002

Some of the markup-phobics have some very valid points
against the implementation of new tags. So let's take
a look at a different approach: 

Make tables separate from the article. Don't embedd them
into the text but just refer to them like you do with 
images. Similar to "upload a new image" we would add
a "create a new table". First it would ask you for a name
of the table and for the number of fields. (You can change
them afterwards, it's just easier to create enough of them
in the beginning)

Then it will show you a mask with an array of textareas
to enter the values of the table. Each Field would have
a few buttons attached to make it merge with the cell
to the right, left, below and above. And a button
to make a coloured background. 

Between each row and column there is a small button to
add a new row/column. And above each column and
in front of each row there's a button to remove the

Each cell of the table will accept all kinds of wiki
markup of course, so you can add images, links, etc to
any cell.

A Preview button will show the rendered table.

Perhaps one wants to show the merge-buttons only upon
request for keeping the display simple.

I'm not sure whether this will become a PITA to edit
a large amount of tables, and perhaps one would add an 
alternative text-markup entry page to create a table 
"the old way" for us keyboard junkies and mouse haters.

Those two table entry modes would have to be equivalent
and tables created by the one have to be editable using
the other method, of course.



More information about the Wikipedia-l mailing list