[Wikimedia-l] Under block threat on fr.wp because of request on meta
alhen.wiki at gmail.com
Sat Nov 3 12:32:39 UTC 2012
*1.* We have no arbcom on es.wiki.
*2. *I was choosen as a checkuser by our last arbcom
*3.* Now, the community created a different process to appoint
checkusers(After more than 3 years or so).
Teofilo, if the community has decided to go without an arbcom and leave
things like the way they are, I suggest you accept it. Asking the removal
of checkuser rights without community support is indeed a bad move.
alhen at wikipedia, wikihow, wikispaces, and most places.
Promotor de Wikimedia Bolivia
2012/11/3 Teofilo <teofilowiki at gmail.com>
> A group of French admins is threatening me of what they call a "block
> with consequences" in the case I would perform any "similar move", a
> move similar with what I did which they interpret as "disrupting
> Wikipedia to illustrate a point" (1).
> As the wording is totally vague ("similar move") this deprives me of
> the right to express myself on community matters. My freedom of speech
> on community matters is being denied.
> What I did, was a request to stewards on meta to remove access for all
> current French Checkusers as a consequence of the French Wikipedia
> switching from the "wiki with arbcom" to the "wiki without arbcom"
> status (2).
> So I am under threat, because I tried to enforce the checkuser policy,
> which provides different access procedures according to whether the
> wiki is with or without arbcom (3).
> Would it be possible to provide some kind of protection to users
> making requests on meta in reference to WMF policies ?
> Would it be possible to have some kind of "meta-arbcom" that would be
> a supreme court responsible for guaranteeing a set of fundamental
> principles, such as freedom of speech ?
> (3) http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/CheckUser_policy#Access_to_CheckUser
> See also:
> [The community vote in 2005 where checkusers where agreed by only a
> very short majority (52.4%)]
> Wikimedia-l mailing list
> Wikimedia-l at lists.wikimedia.org
> Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimedia-l
More information about the Wikimedia-l