[Foundation-l] Flagged Protection update for April 29

[William Pietri]

On 04/30/2010 03:28 PM, Thomas Dalton wrote:
> On 29 April 2010 22:24, William Pietri<william at scissor.com>  wrote:
>    
>> As requested, here's the weekly Flagged Protection update.
>>
>>
>> We continue to work on UI display issues and on getting up a Labs
>> version of the German Wikipedia. We're pretty close to release, and we
>> believe only minor UI issues remain.
>>      
> You are nowhere near ready for release. I reported several significant
> problems here:
>
> http://flaggedrevs.labs.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia:FlaggedRevs_issues#Reviewing_edits
>
> None of them has been fixed and you haven't replied to my bug report
> with any reasons for not fixing them.
>
> You have been commenting that people have been reporting fewer and
> fewer problems; what do you expect if you completely ignore the ones
> people have already reported?
>    


Hi. Thanks for the comment.

Just to be clear, we didn't completely ignore that comment, or any 
other; we've been going through the comments on phone meetings every 
week. We did, however, fail to respond to that one, which I'm sorry for. 
I'll make sure to bring these up next we talk. Going back through, out 
of 26 comments, I see 3 that didn't get replies, so I'll be sure to get 
those, too. Thanks.

So i can be sure I understand, when you say "nowhere near ready for 
release", are you referring just to those 3 issues? I believe the 
question of speed there has mainly to do with labs, rather than Flagged 
Revs itself, and the other 2 points you mention are suggested UI 
improvements. From your phrasing, I take it you believe those UI changes 
are important enough to delay release?

Thanks,

William