[WikiEN-l] Wikipedia and "indecent" content

geni geniice at gmail.com
Tue Dec 23 02:14:16 UTC 2008


2008/12/23 Thomas Larsen <larsen.thomas.h at gmail.com>:
>> A) Yes it's appropriate, because we claim to be not censored.  We  already
>> do
>> tons of things that Brittanica doesn't do, so it's not fair to try to
>> compare us to any other encyclopedia.  We are a new item.
>
> We claim to be an encyclopedia.
>
>> B) Yes it's in accordance with the standards we have established.
>
> No, because one of our standards is "Wikipedia is an encyclopedia",
> and that means "Wikipedia provides the summary of all knowledge in
> accordance with good scholarly practices". The English language may be
> changing, but I think that the word "encyclopedia" still has this
> meaning and association.
>
> —Thomas Larsen


Scholarly practices such as they exist in the field of popular music
have long established that if you are going to talk about an album
cover you show the thing.


-- 
geni



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list