[WikiEN-l] an interesting article

Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton at gmail.com
Sun Aug 3 01:22:33 UTC 2008


> should the en-wiki be
> encouraging the 'news' type items over to Wikinews, or embracing them as a
> core strength of the project....

I'd say news ought to be kept on Wikinews. Wikipedia reporting on
current affairs tends to result in timeline articles and new bits keep
getting added to the end. Major events tend to get enough attention
that someone sooner or later refactors them into decent articles, but
lesser (but still notable) events get left as "As of 17th April, ... .
As of 18th April, ... . As of the afternoon of 18th April, ... . etc".
Reporting the news on Wikinews and then writing a quality article
after the fact would result in Wikinews getting the attention it
deserves and Wikipedia getting good encyclopaedic articles.



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list