[WikiEN-l] Banality threshold

[Thatcher131 Wikipedia]

I once suggested a 24 hour grace period for new articles, after
dealing with several improper A7 requests that had the effect of
driving away the article's creators.  I was told that it would be "too
hard" for the recent change/recent page patrol to keep track of new
articles for 24 hours to see if they improved.

Can we modify A7 to work like unsourced images?  Drop on a template
that says, "This article may not meet guidelines and may be deleted
after 48 hours unless these concerns are addressed; use read the
[[rules]] and use {{help me}} for advice."

Thatcher

On 9/29/07, Nick <heligolandwp at googlemail.com> wrote:
> Is there anything wrong with setting a time limit of say, 60 minutes, on
> speedy deletions, so an article can be tagged, but the author has another 60
> minutes to finish editing the article, and if it's still not notable after
> they've been working on it, it can go. Obviously, the dubious attack crap
> and gibberish would be exempt, but everything else would be covered.
>