[WikiEN-l] Another "BADSITES" controversy

Blu Aardvark jeffrey.latham at gmail.com
Wed May 30 17:34:22 UTC 2007


jayjg wrote:
> Actually, I can't think of any occasion where such a link would be
> beneficial to the project. What exactly did you have in mind?
>   

Let's suppose there was an RFA candidate who had posted to one of the 
aforementioned sites some questionable material. Would it not be 
beneficial to the product to point this out, and would, in some such 
circumstances, a link be necessary? And don't forgot my ArbCom 
case/lynching. Do you seriously mean to imply that it was absolutely 
wrong of the arbitration circlejerk to link to an alleged personal 
attack I made against you that was posted on that forum?

There may be other occasions, not related to bad-faith or questionable 
actions on the part of people, where a link may be beneficial for the 
purpose of discussion. While I can't exactly think of an examples, such 
a situation certainly could appear.



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list