[WikiEN-l] Have we ever had a reader complaint of a lack of spoiler tags?
Delirium
delirium at hackish.org
Thu May 24 19:32:12 UTC 2007
Ken Arromdee wrote:
> On Thu, 24 May 2007, Skyring wrote:
>
>> In deference to the uptothemoment nature of Wikipedia, I'll support spoiler
>> warnings for recent works of fiction and movies. Shakespeare or Tom Clancy,
>> no - they belong to the ages.
>>
>
> I assume then you completely disagree with the claim that spoilers are
> original research? After all, we can't allow original research just for
> articles about newer subjects, we must completely eliminate it.
>
I don't like spoiler warnings myself, but the argument that they're
"original research" is frankly beyond silly, and starting to grasp at
straws. By that standard all Wikipedia articles are completely original
research, as they all involve judgment calls about how to present
information to the reader.
-Mark
More information about the WikiEN-l
mailing list