[WikiEN-l] You're magically made an admin. What do you do?

Anthony wikimail at inbox.org
Thu May 10 02:07:00 UTC 2007


On 5/9/07, Todd Allen <toddmallen at gmail.com> wrote:
> From what I saw, most of those the webcomic articles -were- crud, and
> that includes many that got kept. Most of them were trivially, if at
> all, mentioned in any secondary reliable sources, they were full of
> original research (effectively unfixable, due to that lack of
> secondary sources), and the main arguments for keeping were ILIKEIT
> from fans. If some webcomic is genuinely going to be of long-lasting,
> truly encyclopedic value, it'll get covered by secondary sources, and
> we can have an article. Until then, we don't need articles about
> passing web fads.
>
I don't really disagree with any of that.  But an article can be full
of original research, and be about a comic which isn't mentioned in
any secondary reliable sources, but still be useful.

It wouldn't be useful for Wikipedia, but still something I'd like to
have access to.  It's actually a good example of the reason I'd like
to be able to access deleted articles.  Useless in Wikipedia doesn't
mean useless altogether.

Anthony



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list