[WikiEN-l] Category destruction

Bryan Derksen bryan.derksen at shaw.ca
Wed May 2 09:21:40 UTC 2007


K P wrote:
> A question I've asked a million things, then how do you categorize things
> that come in already created categories that have more than 50 members? For
> example, plant families can't be categories, because there are too many with
> over 50 members, horticultural varieties of a specific species cannot be
> categories because you can't have more than 50ish members, the
> "substantially useful" size of a category.  Varieties of sage should be
> broken up precisely how to conform to the category scheme, and doesn't this
> wind up being original research when dealing with organism categories?

50 members is not a hard limit, just like 32kb is not a hard limit on
article size. If there's a large category that cannot be reasonably
subdivided, then it cannot be subdivided and that's that. A very large
category is still more useful than one that's been arbitrarily split up
or that doesn't exist at all.

In the case of plant families, though, I don't see why they can't be
divided into genera subcategories should the need arise.



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list