[WikiEN-l] Radical redefinition of OR

[Ken Arromdee]

On Wed, 21 Mar 2007, Ray Saintonge wrote:
> It strikes me as unethical to retain information which we know to be 
> wrong simply because the document which establishes the correct 
> information is not in an acceptable format.  If we are to remove the 
> information about her correct age we must also remove the information 
> about the age which we know to be false.

This, oddly, combines two threads, because this very point was one of my
disagreements with WP:ATT.  There was a discussion about whether
attributable but false information must remain.  The result...  it was
impossible to gain consensus for it being permissible to delete such
information.