[WikiEN-l] Let's get rid of the term "meatpuppet"

Ron Ritzman ritzman at gmail.com
Thu Mar 15 02:24:37 UTC 2007


In calling someone a "meatpuppet" we are acknowledging that they are
distinct individuals but we are also suggesting that someone else is
"pulling his strings" which can be considered insulting.

A better term would be "posse". In real life, "posses" are groups of
people who are not full time law enforcement officers who come
together for one purpose, usually the hunting of a fugitive. On
Wikipedia, a "posse" would be a group of people who either form
"single purpose accounts" or have inactive accounts coming together
for a single issue such as participating in an AFD or RFA debate. In
such a debate, "posses" should be given no more weight then a single
active contributor just as is true with "puppets" currently. However,
we shouldn't say that "posses" are outright prohibited.

Why the change, because it would acknowledge that a given "posse"
member, while initially here for one issue, might have his own reasons
for creating an SPA and is not necessarily a slave to a puppetmaster.
He might even discover that he likes it here and become a good
contributor in his own right. I think this would better conform to the
concept of "assume good faith".



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list