[WikiEN-l] No "list of X" article unless there's already a good "X" article
saintonge at telus.net
Mon Jul 16 22:09:17 UTC 2007
Guy Chapman aka JzG wrote:
>On Mon, 16 Jul 2007 09:02:06 -0700, Ray Saintonge wrote:
>>A lot depends on the saus that you accord to "List" articles. I tend to
>>treat them as a combination Index and To-do reference. Until standard
>>practice in books requires references to the index of the book, I don't
>>see why we should be so taken with ourselves as to require references there.
>I would say that it comes rather from the way the list is compiled.
>Some lists are compiled from the editors' best guess at whether they
>meet the criteria, or are sourced form the International Journal of
>Everybody Knows, which as you will be aware is a notoriously
By treating IJEK as a standard reference for lists we are able to keep a
significant inventory of work to be done.
More information about the WikiEN-l