[WikiEN-l] Troubling news on Citizendium

Delirium delirium at hackish.org
Wed Jan 17 21:12:44 UTC 2007


Fred Bauder wrote:
> Unless I have gotten the personalities mixed up, Stan is himself an certified expert employed in an academic setting, which is one reason he can make such an incisive comment about Larry.

Indeed I think this is a general feature.  I was a lot more deferent 
towards experts before I went into academia---once you find out how the 
sausage is made, and even occasionally get deferred to yourself in an 
area where you know your word has no business being accepted 
unquestioningly, it's hard to view it in as idealized a fashion.  I'd 
say most of the academics I know on Wikipedia are *less* deferent 
towards credentials than most of the non-academics are (with some 
exceptions).

-Mark




More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list