[WikiEN-l] Spam and advertising dilemma

[Steve Bennett]

On 1/17/07, Thomas Dalton <thomas.dalton at gmail.com> wrote:
> If there is no article, but the website is notable, you have a choice
> of redlinking, or making a stub. Either is good.

What if the website isn't *that* notable? I'm not that familiar with
the notability standards for websites, but it must be a tough barrow
to shove sometimes. Is it a contradiction to say a website is notable
enough for some given list, but not for a whole article?

Actually I'm sure it's not...you could easily imagine a list in an
article that was "websites set up by John X". They would be noteworthy
for that context, but not noteworthy in general.

Steve