[WikiEN-l] [[New anti-Semitism]] and violations of NPOV re: top image

[Scott Stevenson]

No one's responded to me about why NPOV shouldn't be followed in adding to
the caption the quote from the image's source (Zombie of Zombietime.com)
"Zombie of Zombietime.com describes this poster as, "the most anti-Semitic
sign ever seen at any protest rally in the United States." I've just been
presented with straw man arguments. I've got no problem with the image but
what I do have a problem with is when an image is presented outside of
neutral point of view.

-Scott [[User:Netscott]]

On 8/24/06, jayjg <jayjg99 at gmail.com> wrote:
>
>
> As the article Talk: page has made quite clear, some people look at
> the image and think it is a clear example of anti-Semitism, others
> look at it and think it's anti-Zionism. The article discusses at
> length the debate over whether some (or all) anti-Zionism is
> anti-Semitism - indeed, to a degree, that is what the whole article is
> about.  Thus, again, as has been explained, the arguably ambiguous
> nature of the image is a perfect example of the topic of the article
> itself.
>
> Something about this image bothers Netscott, and he has tried to
> modify, explain, remove, etc. this image on various grounds. He keeps
> claiming it violates policy; yet when asked to explain what policy he
> thinks it violates, he keeps making vague (and changing) references to
> various policies, but refuses to actually quote the specific section
> of policy he thinks this violates.  If there's any wikilawyering going
> on, it's Netscott's claim that something violated policy, but refusal
> to actually quote the policy.
>
> In addition, I find it tiresome that people bring their article
> content disputes to this list. This is the fourth place Netscott has
> insisted on having this discussion; on the article Talk: page, on my
> Talk: page, on WP:AN/I, and now here. If he wants to raise an article
> RfC let him do so.
>
> Jay.
> _______________________________________________
> WikiEN-l mailing list
> WikiEN-l at Wikipedia.org
> To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit:
> http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
>