[WikiEN-l] Re: New Ideas for AfD

[Phil Boswell]

"Anthony DiPierro" wrote:
On 10/26/05, David Gerard wrote:
> MacGyverMagic/Mgm wrote:
> > >I don't care about the number of votes. If an expert can assert it
> > >meets notability criteria it should be kept. We should try to get such
> > >criteria for as many types of articles as possible.
> > Tell the people on AFD. (And I dare you to quote actual policy.) They
> > seriously argue that a consensus of the admittedly ignorant on a
> > subject beats a dissenting actual no-foolin' expert.
> If an actual no-foolin' expert dissents, then there isn't consensus in the
> first place.

You appear to have misunderstood the working definition of "consensus" 
employed on AFD...YHL HAND
-- 
Phil
[[en:User:Phil Boswell]]
Yes, I am bitter about it...why, does it show?