[WikiEN-l] Re: Article size consistency 32k

[David Gerard]

Timwi (timwi at gmx.net) [050523 11:37]:
> John R. Owens wrote:

> >I don't know if this might have ever been suggested before already, 
> >but perhaps a change in software could allow us to set a maximum 
> >image size in our user preferences? Either in width/height, e.g. 
> >"always shrink images to less than 200 pixels wide or 150 pixels 
> >high, whichever is smaller", or in kB, e.g. "always shrink images to 
> >less than 10 kB".
 
> This is absolutely brilliant. I love and support this idea.
 

Sounds good to me too.


> Not because I have a slow connection (which I do, but I don't mind), but
> rather because I'm getting annoyed when people make images so huge
> because they have a 1280x1024 resolution and they think everyone else
> must have that too. (I even had one replying back to me saying "Not
> everyone has a resolution as low as yours, so please leave the image
> this big!")


We have thumbnailing code, so it does make some sense to have images be
huge on the page and reduced as needed.


> >And of course, you probably wouldn't want the rule applied to Image: 
> >namespace pages.
 
> Yes, you do want it applied to Image:-namespace pages. The actual image
> above it is not part of the page. :)
 

We already have such a size limitation for the Image: pages as an option in
preferences. Perhaps it just needs some even smaller settings.


> >But then again, you might also end up with weird formatting, when the
> >author/editor inserting into a page doesn't know how large the image
> >ends up being displayed.

> People should learn that formatting is more than just looking at what it 
> looks like on *your* screen. Pages must be formatted in such a way that 
> they are readable on any resolution (OK, I guess we can assume a minimum 
> resolution of 800x600, but not more!). Resizing your window is all it 
> takes to check. Once this is done properly, varying sizes of images 
> shouldn't have any adverse effect on the formatting.


This is a matter of editorial judgement. "Image reshuffle" is an occasional
edit summary of mine.


- d.