[WikiEN-l] original research, sources, and verification

Tony Sidaway minorityreport at bluebottle.com
Fri Jan 21 11:14:19 UTC 2005


JAY JG said:
>
>>What if I want to describe the British
>>National Party's official policy on asylum seekers?  Wouldn't the best
>>way to do that be to cite the official policy itself?  It isn't
>>produced by a reputable organisation, but it's pretty authoritative on
>>official published party policy.
>
> That's not the issue.  Citing the National Party on it's own policy is
> perfectly reasonable.  However, the real issues occur when people want
> to  cite webpages like this
> http://www.theforbiddenknowledge.com/hardtruth/fake_invasion.htm on the
>  George Bush article:  to prove that George Bush "first started selling
> drugs  to our children. The drug money was used to finance the deep
> underground  alien bases."

That site is clearly not authoritative on the activities of the younger
Bush.  It is, however, authoritative on the expressed opinions of the
anonymous kook who wrote that piece.




More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list