[WikiEN-l] Evercat v. Libertas

[actionforum at comcast.net]

Shall we say one abuse per month per sysop, use it strategically?

I agree that Evercat should resign, I'd feel differently if after his realization he had repented and reversed the blocking.  BTW, has ANYONE reversed the libertas block yet and explained things to her?

In my case, I think AndyL believed he had a defensible reason (I disagree), but he has also agreed he should have referred it to another sysop and will do so in the future.

                               -- Silverback


> nas ral wrote:
> 
> > Your last act as an admin should be to get another admin to block you
> > for the exact same time that Libertas was erroneously blocked. Its a
> > shame, since you seem like a nice person, and this may have been an
> > unfortunate lapse.
> 
> I really don't think we need to actively punish admins for being human. 
> He was baited, and absent a pattern of abusive behaviour, combined with 
> his clear understanding that his actions were improper and what led to 
> them, Allan needs some sort of pseudo-formal scolding. He doesn't need 
> to be stripped of his adminship or banned.
> _______________________________________________
> WikiEN-l mailing list
> WikiEN-l at Wikipedia.org
> http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l