[WikiEN-l] Parascience subst. pseudoscience
Ray Saintonge
saintonge at telus.net
Wed Dec 21 09:48:12 UTC 2005
Delirium wrote:
> David Gerard wrote:
>
>> And by the way, "pseudoscience" does not imply bad faith; it implies
>> incompetence. The pseudoscientist frequently takes the label as a
>> personal attack because they literally do not understand why what they
>> do is not science at all, even though they sincerely believe in what
>> they are doing.
>
> Well, it really is a personal attack; it means something akin to what
> "quack" means in medicine. It occasionally gets slung around among
> scientists, especially when getting into flamewars about the relative
> merits of various of the "soft sciences", and is rarely considered
> anything but an attack. For example, if I were to say, "although it
> uses many statistics, sociology is more of a pseudoscience than a
> proper science", it's pretty clearly an overt attack on sociology.
Now that McLaren is a convert it wouldn't do for them to criticize her
plans to get a "real" degree in sociology. :-)
Ec
More information about the WikiEN-l
mailing list