[WikiEN-l] A list at VfD

[Charles Matthews]

Delirium wrote

> I've seen your arguments, but I don't see how they apply to this list.

How about the two red links that will go?

> It's not organized in any particular way except a flat list of
> articles.  That's exactly equivalent to a category, the only difference
> being a technical one of which end it's maintained on ("edit this page"
> on the list, or add/remove articles to the list from the article's side).
>
> Other lists that have some organization I can see an argument for, but
> if it's just a list whose only distinctions are "it's on the list" or
> "it's not on the list", then category membership is equivalent.

How about the fact that RelatedChanges on a category gets you changes
related to the header text only (as far as I can see)?

And please explain which recognised category of articles for deletion this
falls under?

Charles