[WikiEN-l] Re: recipes

[Charles Matthews]

Gareth Owen wrote

> "Charles Matthews" writes
>
> > Until a recent VfD experience, that was, with a mathematical article
where
> > the 'keeps' really couldn't know why the content was objectionable, and
> > precisely 'diminishing' to WP.
>
> Can you be more specific please, so we can look up what you're referring
to.

Certainly - [[unifying conjecture]] survived VfD recently.  It was a load of
tendentious sociological twaddle by a once-notorious now-banned user.  It
seems that 'looks interesting' is enough in some quarters.  After the vote I
moved it to [[unifying theories in mathematics]], to give context to the one
sentence that wasn't pretty well false as it stood.  That's not a finished
article, though it's not bad, by the way.

Charles