[WikiEN-l] Re: Arbitration: Case of Theresa Knott and Mr. Natural Health

[Anthere]

uninvited at nerstrand.net a écrit:
> The arbitration committee has issued these findings in the matter of Theresa knott and Mr-Natural-Health:
> 
> * we find that Mr-Natural-Health has behaved inappropriately on a consistent and excessive basis
> * we find that Mr-Natural-Health has made personal attacks in violation of Wikipedia's policy
> * we find that Mr-Natural-Health has misused edit summaries in an effort to intimidate other editors
> * therefore, Mr-Natural-Health’s privilege to edit Wikipedia be revoked for a period of 30 days, effective beginning 11 Feb 2004 00:25
> * This revocation to include all Wikimedia wikis, and enforced using technical measures only if necessary.
> * Further, all editors are encouraged to revert any questionable edits made by Mr-Natural-Health without discussion or concurrence of the community for a period of 30 days following his return to the community at the end of the revocation period.
> 
> This, together with the discussion history and vote tally, is available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration
> 
> Respectfully submitted
> 
> UninvitedCompany

------

 > * This revocation to include all Wikimedia wikis, and enforced using 
technical measures only if necessary.

Something suddenly spring to my mind...

What do you mean all wikimedia wikis ?
When was it decided that the english arbitration committee would decide 
who is allowed to edit or not to edit on another language wikipedia ?
How do you plan to tell other languages of your decisions ?
How do you plan to inforce us to obey the english committee decisions ?
What does happen if say...Lir was writing french, and french people 
decided to ban him...would you all accept that naturally our decision to 
ban him is necessarily a decision that all wikipedias immediately have 
to respect ?
What about local rights ?

Of course, you may argue that the committee was chosen by Jimbo, and 
that as such, it takes decisions over all wikipedias...but then...why 
would only the english have this right ? And again, how do you plan to 
communicate (I saw no communication on the matter) and to inforce this 
decision of you ?