[WikiEN-l] Response to Edmund Poor, Ray Saintonge and Sean Barrett

[Poor, Edmund W]

Libertarian,

Thank you for your detailed, point by point response.

I have written you and Brian Corr privately, responding to the proposal
you both made. I don't intend to discuss that proposal on the list,
because mediation works better without an audience.

As for calmness, I hope I've shown enough of it to interest you in my
(free) services as a mediator. 

I appreciate your efforts to seek a resolution. Coming to the mailing
list and asking for help is the proper thing to do, and you have done it
well! :-)

All POVs about a controversy are welcome, if they are attributed to
their advocates. (Note that you and I are not considered advocates. I
mean someone like a member of Parliament, or a famous journalist.)

Facts are good. Let's put plenty of them in the articles. If any facts
are disputed, let's write about the dispute. Like:

* Vishnachristy said the fire occurred accidentally.
* Krishnamurta said Muslims started the fire deliberately.

Note that the article will not tell the reader which source to believe.
It will only indicate WHAT each source SAID.

I'm sorry that it took so long for you to get help. We are not a mature
organization, and the only person officially in charge of "helping" is
the website owner, Jimbo Wales. He's very busy, but he hasn't appointed
any official assistants yet. So we are all volunteers.

In my case, I postponed my offer of help until AFTER I was convinced
that you were more interested in cooperation than in retaliation. Puzzle
over THAT for a while, eh?

I hope that as a result of my offer to help, there will be a lot less
branding. We can't reach our mutual goal by inflicting scorching pain on
each other.

If you are willing to take the time to work together on making a neutral
article, I will help.

Ed Poor
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/wikien-l/attachments/20031112/6205121e/attachment.htm