[WikiEN-l] Do we really want to confuse every American who reads the Wikipedia?

The Cunctator cunctator at kband.com
Mon Mar 3 04:10:16 UTC 2003


So, at 

[[[Wikipedia_talk:Manual_of_Style_(dates_and_numbers)]], about 30 people
have been engaged in a discussion about changing the [[Month Day]] standard
format. 

At some point someone set up a voting scheme, listing some options, and
people tagged their preference. In a shocking development, most of the
people who voted for making [[Day Month]] Wikipedia policy are British.

Without getting (again) into the how very bad voting is for making a
decision, I'll simply say that what is needed is to

Construct a consensus document on the merits and problems of each proposal.

Not to vote.

A 30-person vote != democratic decision.

And we should be looking for the best decision for Wikipedia, not
necessarily the most popular.

I'll leave discussion of the specific merits and problems for the webpages,
though Zoe has well elucidated a major issue with the subject of this
thread. 




More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list