[WikiEN-l] The Lir situation

[Erik Moeller]

>> I suggest that Zoe can be Lir's mentor; if Lir ignores Zoe, then only he
>> is to blame for whatever action she uses her sysop powers for to deal
>> with him.  Not only is it poetic justice, but I feel Lir has progressed
>> enough that spending time deliberately trying not to piss off Zoe would
>> complete the polish on his Wiki-indoctrination and make him the valued
>> contributor we all know he is capable of being.

> I can't decide whether Jonathan is showing Gandhi-esque genius for the
> resolution of a tough problem, or being the matchmaker for a romance
> from hell.  They'd have to talk together.

The whole idea of a mentor system (which I proposed) rests on the fact  
that the person being mentored acknowledges the mentor as someone they  
respect, not that the "mentor" can punish the "pupil" to "complete the  
polish on his Wiki-indoctrination" (Clutch's words - the same Clutch who  
repeatedly vandalized Lir's user page to instill "good taste" into her).

Aside from that, this goes far beyond the purposes for which sysop powers  
are intended and moves us away from a wiki-community to one ruled by  
editorial police forces who can reign arbitrarily with no process of  
appeal, much like Everything2.

One thing is clear: There are more grounds to ban Clutch, based on his  
past behavior, than to ban Lir.

Regards,

Erik