[Foundation-l] About the low-hanging fruit
Yaroslav M. Blanter
putevod at mccme.ru
Fri Jun 10 12:29:26 UTC 2011
>> You have an expert knowledge in this topic, namely the knowledge of
>> Russian language. Most of English Wikipedia editors don't.
>>
<...>
>
> Most unilingual English editors are surprised by the vast quantity of
> low hanging fruit. Out of curiosity at one time I looked up the fairly
> common Spanish name "Reyes" in the original 70 volume "Enciclopedia
> universal ilustrada". I found 30 individuals there with that simple
> uncompounded surname. Only two of these appeared in the English
> Wikipedia, and only one of the two in the Spanish Wikipedia. Could
> something similar be said of the great Soviet Encyclopedia? I have
> before looked at a couple short encyclopedic works in Russian, one
> relating to hockey and one to movies. Both did address their subject as
> it related to the United States as well as their own country. Comparably
> sized American publications would leave the reader wondering if there
> even was such a thing as a Russian film industry. The dismissive
> attitude that Russian works were written by Communists becomes quite
> thin in subjects that are inherently apolitical.
>
Indeed, 7 out of 19 articles I created over three weeks are in Great
Soviet Encyclopaedia (and about a dozen of more among those I expanded as
well). One of these (on a folklorist Anna Astakhova, which I started today)
does not exist in Russian Wikipedia. Admittedly all of them (in GSE, not
those I created) are very short and hardly useful for creation a Wikipedia
article - although GSE gives a clear proof of notability, just in case.
Cheers
Yaroslav
More information about the foundation-l
mailing list