[Foundation-l] Moderate this list

[Pavlo Shevelo]

> I believe what was meant by this is that we should codify policies the
> same way that all large Wikipedias have codified policies, NOT that we
> should adopt the same policies as en.wp or any other for that matter.

If we're talking about Wikipedias - yes.
But if we are talking about moderation policies for this particular
mailing list (what was and still is the context - if I'm not mistaken)
codification will not work:
moderator will ban me (it's only mind game I do hope :) ) according to
en:WP rules, I will appeal according to uk:WP rules and, say, Yaroslav
will object my appeal according to ru:WP rules  while you will support
my appeal according to some other rules.

Or you mean 'codification' as 'put all rules systematically/structured
and in written'?
If so it's exactly the basic proposal of Anders Wennersten:

> -Document wanted behavior rules on meta in the same way as on wikipedia
> (wp:et, wp:not, no chat, do not overload etc)

and perhaps Yaroslav  just missed "in the same way as" and understood
that as proposal to adopt en:WP rules without any adaptation to
multicultured (did I used the proper word?) community of this mailing
list and/or Meta


On Sat, Sep 12, 2009 at 12:47 AM, Mark Williamson <node.ue at gmail.com> wrote:
>>>> -Document wanted behavior rules on meta in the same way as on wikipedia
>>>> (wp:et, wp:not, no chat, do not overload etc)
>>
>> What wikipedia? I have no idea what the en.wp rules are for discussions,
>> and I do not wnat to be blocked on this list for not having this idea. On
>> ru.wp, my home project, we may very well use different rules.
>
> I believe what was meant by this is that we should codify policies the
> same way that all large Wikipedias have codified policies, NOT that we
> should adopt the same policies as en.wp or any other for that matter.
>
> Mark
>
> _______________________________________________
> foundation-l mailing list
> foundation-l at lists.wikimedia.org
> Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
>