[Foundation-l] A question for the Wikimania jury

[Andrew Whitworth]

On Mon, Mar 31, 2008 at 6:54 PM, Aphaia <aphaia at gmail.com> wrote:
>  Criteria was on meta for months and you had have a lot of time but
>  definitely less than any jury member to spare the time to give your
>  consideration and feedback to its talk page.

This may be, but people are still asking questions about how this
decision was reached, what criteria the Jury used and what those
criteria mean. And regardless of what the page says at meta, nobody
really knows what the Jury members were thinking when they voted, or
what they discussed amongst themselves in private. Then, when the
decision has been made, there seems to be no venue presented and no
tolerance displayed for people who have questions, comments, or
concerns about it.

Having a talk page on meta hardly means that the process is an "open" one.

--Andrew Whitworth