David Gerard escribió:
On 13/10/2007, Erik Moeller erik@wikimedia.org wrote:
On 10/13/07, David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com wrote:
http://www.calacanis.com/2007/02/20/technological-obscurification-three-ways...
His name is Calacanis,
And it's right there in the URL. I suppose this is what I get for including a vocabulary flame.
and it's an old thread - but IMHO quite relevant to the discussion about slowing growth.
Yes, which is why I forwarded it.
Good WYSIWYG in a wiki is hard; even Wikia hasn't solved that particular problem yet. Hopefully we'll make serious progress on it next year. The LiquidThreads discussion extension which could replace talk pages is now in production use e.g. on WikiEducator.org ; all it needs is a champion within the Wikimedia community.
Really? That's excellent :-)
The comment I added to the discussion was:
===
- The main problem is that MediaWiki wikitext does not have a defined
syntax - the definition is quite literally the PHP code - and is mathematically impossible to put into EBNF. (Many have tried, got to 95% and realised it wasn't actually possible.) So there are no alternate parsers, and no WYSIWYG can cover the lot. But 95% coverage in a WYSIWYG editor should get most of the useful bits.
FCKeditor looks like the best prospect for a WYSIWYG MediaWiki editor at present. It's not there yet, but I hold out hope for the near to medium future.
- Talk pages are indeed a crappy forum format. There are various
extensions to help improve this - Uncyclopedia uses the forum extension to good effect (wikitext pages but with a forumlike main page) and the LiquidThreads extension is undergoing serious work.
- On this one, I think you're plain wrong. (a) IRC is damn useful,
but you do not in any way have to be on IRC to be a productive Wikipedia editor, admin or even arbitrator. And many aren't and won't be. (b) I find it hard to conceive how any Internet idiot can lower the world's collective IQ with instant messaging, but thinking people who would want to contribute to an encyclopedia can't. And IRC is IM based around chatrooms instead of one-to-one. If you can use Trillian or GAIM/Pidgin, you can use IRC.
There was a proposal on may[1] about having cgi-irc gateway on the toolserver but it was rejected[2]. Time to rethink it?
Other solutions include the Java client[3] and Wikizine cgi-irc[4] which seem to have added most of our channels.
1-http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/toolserver-l/2007-May/000759.html 2-http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/toolserver-l/2007-May/000765.html 3-http://tools.wikimedia.de/~bjelleklang/pjirc/index.php 4-http://chatwikizine.memebot.com/cgi-bin/cgiirc/irc.cgi
On 13/10/2007, Platonides Platonides@gmail.com wrote:
There was a proposal on may[1] about having cgi-irc gateway on the toolserver but it was rejected[2]. Time to rethink it? Other solutions include the Java client[3] and Wikizine cgi-irc[4] which seem to have added most of our channels.
cgi-irc is unbelievably horrible to use - you'd have to really be desperate.
A Java client is a better idea. Chatzilla is available as an add-on for Firefox (or as part of Seamonkey) and is an excellent IRC client.
- d.
David Gerard wrote:
On 13/10/2007, Platonides wrote:
There was a proposal on may[1] about having cgi-irc gateway on the toolserver but it was rejected[2]. Time to rethink it? Other solutions include the Java client[3] and Wikizine cgi-irc[4] which seem to have added most of our channels.
cgi-irc is unbelievably horrible to use - you'd have to really be desperate.
A Java client is a better idea. Chatzilla is available as an add-on for Firefox (or as part of Seamonkey) and is an excellent IRC client.
- d.
Java clients aren't so good. I prefer CGI-Irc than most Java applets. At least it's light. We can discuss the features the ideal web irc client must have :-)
Obviously, using Chatzilla (with or without Firefox) or another client software is much better. But then people complain it's too hard accessing irc!! They find easier propietary IM protocols like MSN or AOL/ICQ for which they still need a spcific client :-(
Platonides wrote:
David Gerard wrote:
On 13/10/2007, Platonides wrote:
There was a proposal on may[1] about having cgi-irc gateway on the toolserver but it was rejected[2]. Time to rethink it? Other solutions include the Java client[3] and Wikizine cgi-irc[4] which seem to have added most of our channels.
cgi-irc is unbelievably horrible to use - you'd have to really be desperate.
A Java client is a better idea. Chatzilla is available as an add-on for Firefox (or as part of Seamonkey) and is an excellent IRC client.
- d.
Java clients aren't so good. I prefer CGI-Irc than most Java applets. At least it's light. We can discuss the features the ideal web irc client must have :-)
Indeed!. any irc client written in php or perl or python is much better than a monster in java.
--user:alnokta
On 13/10/2007, Mohamed Magdy mohamed.m.k@gmail.com wrote:
Indeed!. any irc client written in php or perl or python is much better than a monster in java.
Is that so? Can you back up that statement and explain why you feel a web gateway is "better" - in what sense? Certainly, it's a lot easier to say, "click this link, you don't need to download or install anything, and it should Just Work(tm)", but at the same time, you're adding a tremendous overhead by having a web server/application stack as the middleman.
Rob Church
On 13/10/2007, Platonides Platonides@gmail.com wrote:
Obviously, using Chatzilla (with or without Firefox) or another client software is much better. But then people complain it's too hard accessing irc!! They find easier propietary IM protocols like MSN or AOL/ICQ for which they still need a spcific client :-(
Specific client? Pidgin, for example, handles all these.
Of course people are going to find such things easier; IRC is not championed in the same manner that, e.g. MSN Messenger are; it's not as straightforward as installing the "official" client and following some simple instructions on an "official" web site, and the management and service provision are backed up by non-household names, which operate in a far more ad-hoc fashion.
Rob Church
On 10/14/07, Platonides Platonides@gmail.com wrote:
Obviously, using Chatzilla (with or without Firefox) or another client software is much better. But then people complain it's too hard accessing irc!! They find easier propietary IM protocols like MSN or AOL/ICQ for which they still need a spcific client :-(
The difficulty of installing a new client is low for most users compared with the difficulty of learning all the text-based commands needed to operate IRC. IRC is like DOS in the Windows world of IM.
On 10/13/07, Stephen Bain stephen.bain@gmail.com wrote:
The difficulty of installing a new client is low for most users compared with the difficulty of learning all the text-based commands needed to operate IRC. IRC is like DOS in the Windows world of IM.
Generally speaking, it should be noted, modern GUI IRC clients will allow you to do pretty much anything you want through context menus and so on. But for one thing, how to take any particular action varies from client to client, so you have to find someone using the same client to be able to get GUI instructions, and that means people just give the text command if someone asks. For another thing, even the nice GUI clients tend not to be helpful enough to explain even things as simple as what an op is (mostly they have some unexplained symbol next to their name), let alone how to understand the arcane gibberish that constitutes a ban, or why most of the chat room mysteriously left and then returned after a couple of minutes and nobody seemed to find it remarkable.
IMO, something like MSN Messenger is easier to learn and use than *any* IRC client, due to issues that strike down all the way to the protocol level. You literally can't be an effective op on IRC without having a working knowledge of DNS, for instance, and no IRC client can realistically help that. If IRC is to ever be competitive with proprietary protocols, it needs an overhaul.
But ultimately, although I've pointed out some disadvantages, they aren't that prohibitive when it comes down to it. Very non-technical users can mostly just download a program, connect to the one channel they want, and talk like in any chat program. They just have to ignore all the weird stuff that they don't need at first, which they'll slowly be forced to learn if they stick around. The difference to a newcomer between IRC and proprietary IM is partly usability but mostly culture. I don't see any problem in sticking with IRC as the primary chat mechanism, for those who want to join official chats.
On Sat, 2007-10-13 at 22:54 +0200, Platonides wrote:
There was a proposal on may[1] about having cgi-irc gateway on the toolserver but it was rejected[2]. Time to rethink it?
Other solutions include the Java client[3] and Wikizine cgi-irc[4] which seem to have added most of our channels.
Why not take the approach that has worked for Perlmonks for many years, with their "Chatterbox"?
http://www.perlmonks.org/index.pl?node_id=3184&displaytype=raw
No need for Java at all to facilitate this.
And they log the last hour in various places:
http://mini-cb60.flux8.com/ http://nbpfaus.net/~pfau/cbhistory.cgi?site=PM
wikitech-l@lists.wikimedia.org