Le 17/08/2012 07:54, Dovi Jacobs a
I understand that in fact you do not strictly critical editions (I
have try to see what you do on he:, but I am absolutely not familiar
with this langage), but compilations of sources, which is quite
different. In that sense, I have nothing to say.
Ah, now I understand what you meant! But why do you
think the editing guidelines will be "without
reference"? Just like a Wikipedia article can and should
be based on sources, the Wikisource guidelines for
editing a text should be written by people familiar with
the scholarship on that text, while referencing both
that scholarship and the relevant editions and
manuscripts. Which is exactly what we try to do. And it
works quite well.