This is in relation to a concern a user brought to my attention on
en.wikipedia.org, and which I posted a note on Jimmy Wale's talk page
about. I was instructed that meta might deal with what I describe, and
I basically followed the links to mailing lists and to here.
Essentially, to distill this, a user on the hebrew wikipedia, Itay,
was blocked from editing his wikipedia over bad blood between him and
one of the admins (essentially he created a list where he detailed
what he believed were one admin's wrongful actions. It was deleted and
he was subsequently blocked.) Upon appealing to other admins, filing
and RfC, which was removed, filing another and another over various
"errors" in the filing process, and appealing directly to the
essential "head" of he.wiki, he went from being blocked for a week to
being permanently banned. I have corresponded with Itay on numerous
occasions and he has links to all the relevant info, and I believe he
has a strong case that the administrators, or at least four of them,
are acting in a totalitarian and outrightly frightening way to block
and remove edits they deem harmful. Even more worrisome is that there
is no way to appeal to have these admins reviewed on he.wiki. I have
received other emails from other users on he.wiki expressing their
similar concern, quote, "The Hebrew Wikipedia is rotten from the top
down. Plenty of wikipedians who could've contributed a lot to he have
been banned or scared off for either no reason or very minor reasons."
Or, to take part of a run-on sentence, "Several admins have even
clearly stated that "some users are more equal than others" (hinting
at admins > registered users > anonymous users). It's impossible to
have a vote within the community to revoke the admins' rights as
people who have opposed them have either been banned or aren't going
to vote against them because if they do and the rights aren't revoked
they'll be picked on".
Frankly, I'm stumped as to where to turn. This went from a simple AMA
request to a whirlwind of tossabouts. What I am sure I need is a
hebrew/english ambassador who's nuetral in this conflict, who I can
send the evidence to confrim (m Hebrew is pretty basic); I also have
trascriptions for anyone interested. I just have no idea what to do
now... I'm appealing to anyone who has an idea of what my action
should now be.
Sincerily,
David Fuchs
--
Ὦ ξεῖν', ἀγγέλλειν Λακεδαιμονίοις ὅτι τῇδε
κείμεθα, τοῖς κείνων ῥήμασι πειθόμενοι.
(Go, stranger, and to Lacedaemon tell,
That here, obeying her behests, we fell)
-Epigram to the Spartans at the Battle of Thermopylae