We
want to keep good people like Zoe, dave (dograt), et al. BUT we don't want to
overdo this banning thing.
Maybe
we should revive the idea of a partial ban:
*
Contributor blocked from editing articles -- stops the edit
war
* But
can still edit talk pages -- which keeps dialogue open
To
maintain impartiality, I propose that parties to the conflict get at least one
other contributor, who is not involved in the conflict, to agree. In other
words, if I'm fighting with Jacob about "Palestinian Territories", I should not
block him -- but Lee (if he agreed Jacob was being anti-Wikipedian) could step
in and block him.
What
do people think about a Selective Block? How would things have been different if
we had done this with any of the following?
*
24
*
Helga (H. Jonat)
*
DW
*
Lir
Ed
Poor
Well, if she comes back and continues to cause trouble, I may have to walk
away from Wikipedia.
Zoe