Chris Nyborg wrote:
I agree, in principle, but I do hope that we can take his slowly.
I agree completely with this part... about taking things slowly. :-)
I would say that the analysis given here was excellent and it made me really happy to read all about it: this is how Wikipedia works when it is working best: people who don't agree on everything taking the time to discuss it at great length and try to find a way to accomodate everyone, and get a sense of the wisest way forward.
Based on this, I don't support the creation of a 3rd wikipedia unless and until the users who want it are able to build a consensus within the community that it is a sensible thing to do.
--Jimbo