The person was not a member at the time, which is a point of contention and which would remain. Even the ratification of renewal of membership and validity of being member of EC with retrospective effect, at this time still would have its own share of questions to be answered satisfactorily.

That said, I am a common wikimedia member and do not really care what happens with the EC or anything around this discussions. I do what I can and would continue doing that.

To be honest, I used to watch what was happening and the different conversations that has been going around this entire fiasco. It have succeeded in alienating a lot of people, so fed-up of all the happenings. I have never seen anyone responsible or answerable, responding to the multiple queries which have been going around then, now or expect that to happen in future as well.

The explanation or discussion is not supposed to happen between us at all at first place.

I have never got out of work or stopped doing what I can to support the movement and hence there is no question of getting back to work. Please request you to not order me around. You may want to do what you have to do.

On Sat, Oct 4, 2014 at 3:14 PM, Vikram Vincent <> wrote:
On 4 October 2014 10:42, Abhilash S Unni <> wrote:
And with all respect to Vincent Vikram, the logic what you are saying would also mean that Ms. Jayalalithaa can continue as Tamil Nadu CM irrespective of her ceasing to be an MLA....!!!

Please give the complete example if you are trying to use an analogy.  She was disqualified and lost CM post due to the conviction and not because she simply ceased to be an MLA.  I believe that an MLC can also be CM, K Rosaiah the present CM of Andhra Pradesh being an MLC.They should only enjoy the support of the majority.

My understanding uses the following examples:

First, holding the post of PM of India
" be a member of the Lok Sabha or the Rajya Sabha. If the person chosen as the prime minister is neither a member of the Lok Sabha nor the Rajya Sabha at the time of selection, he must become a member of either of the houses within six months."

Second, our current MHRD, Ms Smriti Irani lost the MP elections from Amethi, Uttar Pradesh but was still appointed to the post.

So yes, the logic is simple. The EC member held the primary membership and this lapsed due to some reason. And the membership was then renewed.  I believe that the EC can take a decision to ratify the membership and amend the rules as well.

Hope this solves the dilemma. Now can we get back to work?

Wikimediaindia-l mailing list
To unsubscribe from the list / change mailing preferences visit