The Board resolutions from the last meeting are now all public on:
http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolutions
Perhaps the most interesting one from a community point of view is the "Philip Greenspun illustrations project", about which a separate announcement will be posted shortly.
Erik Möller Executive Secretary Wikimedia Foundation
On 02/11/2007, Erik Moeller erik@wikimedia.org wrote:
The Board resolutions from the last meeting are now all public on:
http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolutions
Perhaps the most interesting one from a community point of view is the "Philip Greenspun illustrations project", about which a separate announcement will be posted shortly.
Erik Möller Executive Secretary Wikimedia Foundation
Thanks for that.
Could I ask you, in the interests of transparency and openness and all that, to explain your reasons for abstaining on the resolution to re-appoint Florence as Chair? Other than that and the illustrations project (which you say will be explained soon), everything else seems self-explanatory.
On 11/2/07, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
Could I ask you, in the interests of transparency and openness and all that, to explain your reasons for abstaining on the resolution to re-appoint Florence as Chair?
I have explained my reasons to her privately, and that's how it will remain.
On 02/11/2007, Erik Moeller erik@wikimedia.org wrote:
On 11/2/07, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
Could I ask you, in the interests of transparency and openness and all that, to explain your reasons for abstaining on the resolution to re-appoint Florence as Chair?
I have explained my reasons to her privately, and that's how it will remain.
As an elected member of the board, do you not feel a responsibility to explain your actions to those you represent?
Thomas Dalton wrote:
On 02/11/2007, Erik Moeller erik@wikimedia.org wrote:
On 11/2/07, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
Could I ask you, in the interests of transparency and openness and all that, to explain your reasons for abstaining on the resolution to re-appoint Florence as Chair?
I have explained my reasons to her privately, and that's how it will remain.
As an elected member of the board, do you not feel a responsibility to explain your actions to those you represent?
One needs to make a distinction between votes about resolutions in general and votes where personalities may be involved. If there are personalities involved insisting on reasons can only exacerbate the problem.
Ec
One needs to make a distinction between votes about resolutions in general and votes where personalities may be involved. If there are personalities involved insisting on reasons can only exacerbate the problem.
If a member of the board does not have complete confidence in the chair, that's a serious problem, and I think trying to keep that quiet can only exacerbate the problem. The good of the foundation has to take precedence over Florence's feelings - she made that decision by joining the board.
Thomas Dalton:
If a member of the board does not have complete confidence in the chair, that's a serious problem, and I think trying to keep that quiet can only exacerbate the problem.
If Erik did not believe Ant was a suitable board member, I can only assume he would have voted against the resolution instead of abstaining. An abstention is not a negative vote.
- river.
On 03/11/2007, River Tarnell river@wikimedia.org wrote:
Thomas Dalton:
If a member of the board does not have complete confidence in the chair, that's a serious problem, and I think trying to keep that quiet can only exacerbate the problem.
If Erik did not believe Ant was a suitable board member, I can only assume he would have voted against the resolution instead of abstaining. An abstention is not a negative vote.
"Abstain" generally means "Oppose, but I don't want to cause a fuss".
Thomas Dalton:
"Abstain" generally means "Oppose, but I don't want to cause a fuss".
So Erik opposed his own appointment to the board? (http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolution:Executive_Secretary_term_2007...)
- river.
On 03/11/2007, River Tarnell river@wikimedia.org wrote:
Thomas Dalton:
"Abstain" generally means "Oppose, but I don't want to cause a fuss".
So Erik opposed his own appointment to the board? (http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolution:Executive_Secretary_term_2007...)
"Generally" does not mean "always". Obviously, it's normal to abstain when you have a conflict of interest.
on 11/3/07 9:57 AM, Thomas Dalton at thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
On 03/11/2007, River Tarnell river@wikimedia.org wrote:
Thomas Dalton:
If a member of the board does not have complete confidence in the chair, that's a serious problem, and I think trying to keep that quiet can only exacerbate the problem.
If Erik did not believe Ant was a suitable board member, I can only assume he would have voted against the resolution instead of abstaining. An abstention is not a negative vote.
"Abstain" generally means "Oppose, but I don't want to cause a fuss".
Could he possibly mean "recuse" instead of "abstain"?
Marc
"Abstain" generally means "Oppose, but I don't want to cause a fuss".
Could he possibly mean "recuse" instead of "abstain"?
I think abstain in the right word. It means you choose not to cast a vote on a particular issue. I'm just making a gross generalisation about people's reasons for not casting such votes.
I'm not sure of the strict definition of "recuse". I would say it's a more general thing - abstaining just refers to votes, recusing refers to the entire process. Someone recusing themselves would probably leave the meeting entirely while an issue was being discussed and voted on. (Erik may have done that, I don't know, but there's nothing to suggest he did.)
Thomas Dalton wrote:
One needs to make a distinction between votes about resolutions in general and votes where personalities may be involved. If there are personalities involved insisting on reasons can only exacerbate the problem.
If a member of the board does not have complete confidence in the chair, that's a serious problem, and I think trying to keep that quiet can only exacerbate the problem. The good of the foundation has to take precedence over Florence's feelings - she made that decision by joining the board.
I have had the pleasure of meeting both of these individuals, and would at least assume good faith for both of their efforts. We could speculate about their motives, but that would not be a constructive exercise if it would make it more difficult for them to work together.
Ec
I have had the pleasure of meeting both of these individuals, and would at least assume good faith for both of their efforts. We could speculate about their motives, but that would not be a constructive exercise if it would make it more difficult for them to work together.
Erik says Florence knows the reasons, so telling us won't effect their working relationship. I think the community having faith in the board is more important than being nice to Florence. I can't have faith in a board that apparently doesn't have faith in each other.
On 11/3/07, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
I have had the pleasure of meeting both of these individuals, and would at least assume good faith for both of their efforts. We could speculate about their motives, but that would not be a constructive exercise if it would make it more difficult for them to work together.
Erik says Florence knows the reasons, so telling us won't effect their working relationship. I think the community having faith in the board is more important than being nice to Florence. I can't have faith in a board that apparently doesn't have faith in each other.
Eh, so don't vote for them, and don't donate your money to them. No one's forcing you to.
Eh, so don't vote for them, and don't donate your money to them. No one's forcing you to.
That doesn't help until the next election, does it?
Thomas Dalton wrote:
Eh, so don't vote for them, and don't donate your money to them. No one's forcing you to.
That doesn't help until the next election, does it?
I saw the comment on the vote for Chair, Erik abstained for COI - Conflict Of Interest. I do not want to provoke a flurry of speculation, but that could be something as simple a motion to support/oppose Florence continuing being proposed and Erik opposing, wishing further discussion on who should be chair. Holding such an opinion does not preclude believing Florence is capable of doing a good job, a difference over the order priorities should be addressed in could cause this, but if you agree on the top ten then you're perfectly capable of working together. The friction over what should be addressed first would be behind closed doors, and I trust both Erik and Florence to be reasoned and reasonable in presenting their opinions and consulting with their fellow board members.
To some extent I am surprised people pick over this in such detail. There apparently seem to be some who wish to look for "WikiDrama" where none may exist. If you do not have confidence in a candidate for a position you vote oppose. If you abstain, you are saying they can do the job but you were not offered a choice you wanted.
Brian.
I saw the comment on the vote for Chair, Erik abstained for COI - Conflict Of Interest. I do not want to provoke a flurry of speculation, but that could be something as simple a motion to support/oppose Florence continuing being proposed and Erik opposing, wishing further discussion on who should be chair.
Opposing or abstaining won't result in more discussion - once it reaches a vote, you're too late to get more discussion. I would hope the board don't vote on things before everyone's had a chance to say everything they want to say.
If you abstain, you are saying they can do the job but you were not offered a choice you wanted.
That could well be all it is, or it could be something more serious (and he knew opposing wouldn't actually help, so didn't want to hassle that opposing could cause). That's why I'd like Erik to tell us, and I fail to see any legitimate reason for him not to.
Thomas Dalton wrote:
I saw the comment on the vote for Chair, Erik abstained for COI - Conflict Of Interest. I do not want to provoke a flurry of speculation, but that could be something as simple a motion to support/oppose Florence continuing being proposed and Erik opposing, wishing further discussion on who should be chair.
Opposing or abstaining won't result in more discussion - once it reaches a vote, you're too late to get more discussion. I would hope the board don't vote on things before everyone's had a chance to say everything they want to say.
If you abstain, you are saying they can do the job but you were not offered a choice you wanted.
That could well be all it is, or it could be something more serious (and he knew opposing wouldn't actually help, so didn't want to hassle that opposing could cause). That's why I'd like Erik to tell us, and I fail to see any legitimate reason for him not to.
Erik wrote me privately about two weeks before the meeting, and we had a couple of emails back and fro on the topic. So we both discussed together before the meeting.
Then, during the board meeting in Florida, I left the room to let other board members discuss the issue together. Erik had to the opportunity to present his opinion to other board members, after which all of them voted.
For each officer election, the candidate left the room to let other board members discuss privately, then vote.
Ant
On 11/3/07, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
Eh, so don't vote for them, and don't donate your money to them. No one's forcing you to.
That doesn't help until the next election, does it?
Neither does this.
Hi Erik,
thanks for posting the resolutions. Of course there are lots of details to fuss about, and probably way more important, but I was just wondering... Why are you using Florence's and your nickname and Kat's real name in the resolutions (and not mindspillage)? Is that decided by personal preference, or is there some idea behind it? For instance: http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolution:Whistleblower_policy%2C_updat... It only seems to occus on "non-meeting" resolutions. So probably you just copied it from another wiki. It would be a little more consistent if the naming would be similar in both non-meeting resolutions and meeting-resolutions. (sorry again for the detail-wagging of me)
Just for the sake of kindness to visitors of the website: could you add some kind of symbol or notice if the link goes to a private wiki or another private resource? That way people won't have to click on it. I assume just a matter of layout :) (for board- and officewiki it might even be fixed through the monobook?) Example: http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolution:Budget_approval_2007 linking to boardwiki.
BR, Lodewijk
2007/11/2, Erik Moeller erik@wikimedia.org:
The Board resolutions from the last meeting are now all public on:
http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Resolutions
Perhaps the most interesting one from a community point of view is the "Philip Greenspun illustrations project", about which a separate announcement will be posted shortly.
Erik Möller Executive Secretary Wikimedia Foundation
foundation-l mailing list foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org Unsubscribe: http://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
On 11/3/07, effe iets anders effeietsanders@gmail.com wrote:
Hi Erik,
thanks for posting the resolutions. Of course there are lots of details to fuss about, and probably way more important, but I was just wondering... Why are you using Florence's and your nickname and Kat's real name in the resolutions (and not mindspillage)? Is that decided by personal preference, or is there some idea behind it? For instance:
I have no idea what others' preferences are, but I prefer being referred to by name, and usually change my displayed signature to reflect it. I think these were copied directly from the voting pages and use whatever we used there.
-Kat
wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org