Report to the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
Covering: April 2009 Prepared by: Sue Gardner, Executive Director, Wikimedia Foundation Prepared for: Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
MILESTONES FROM APRIL 1.Berlin Board and Chapters meeting 1.Licensing update vote launched 2.Chief Program Officer hired
KEY PRIORITIES FOR MAY 1.Further development of 2009-10 Annual Plan and staff goals 2.Israeli Wikipedia Academy 3.Begin hiring for Strategy Plan project 4.Implement license update
In April, the Wikimedia Foundation sites held steady as the number four most-popular sites in the world, with 320,043,000 global unique visitors, according to comScore Media Metrix.
CHAPTERS MEETING, BOARD MEETING, & MEDIAWIKI DEVELOPERS CONFERENCE
Many Wikimedia Foundation staff attended the All Chapters meeting, Board meeting, and MediaWiki developers conference in Berlin in early April.
The following people gave workshops: Frank Schulenburg gave a workshop on public outreach; Rand Montoya gave a workshop on fundraising; Erik Moeller gave a workshop on the Chapters Funding Request process, and Mike Godwin gave a workshop on trademarks.
Sue Gardner and James Owen attended the Board of Trustees meeting, which was held concurrent with the All Chapters meeting. Key agenda items at the Board of Trustees meeting included a recap of the 2009-2010 Annual Plan development process and solicitation of Board member feedback; a discussion of Biographies of Living People, approval to proceed with the Strategic Planning project, and a discussion of trademark policy and practices. During the closing session of the All Chapters meeting, the Board and Sue announced the Strategy project, and participated in a general discussion about it.
Concurrent with the All Chapters and Board of Trustees meetings, Wikimedia Germany developer Daniel Kinzler organized a conference for MediaWiki developers. It was attended by Wikimedia Foundation technical staff Brion Vibber, Tomasz Finc, Mark Bergsma, Tim Starling, Trevor Parscal and Arash Boostani. Many volunteer developers from Europe and elsewhere also attended. Among the many productive discussions, the most notable was a decision to integrate maps from OpenStreetMap, a free and open mapping project, in Wikimedia projects. A project to set up a map tile server mirror locally in our Amsterdam hosting cluster is underway, and development is ongoing on a functional inline map display widget.
The Wikimedia Foundation congratulates Wikimedia Germany on successfully organizing a very useful and productive conference.
TECHNOLOGY
Fred Vassard began improvements to operations infrastructure such as spam filtering, logging, and status monitoring as well as investigating commercial monitoring options.
After discussion with Manuel Schneider from the OpenZim project, the OpenZim format was identified as a likely target for future offline distributions such as DVD and USB stick versions of Wikipedia. Tomasz Finc will explore integration of OpenZim into the dump process, once the primary issues around database dump reliability are fully addressed.
The Wikimedia Foundation officially opted out of the “Phorm” traffic-scanning targeted-advertising system which is being rolled out by some ISPs in the UK. This may be a largely symbolic measure: it is intended to demonstrates the Wikimedia Foundation's commitment to Internet freedom and privacy for the Wikimedia Foundation's users.
In April, the team began soliciting more active testing for the new mobile gateway at m.wikipedia.org, which is targeted for a full public release later this year.
Other areas of department focus:
* Tim Starling is preparing an upcoming MediaWiki 1.15 release, which addresses some low-level data storage and installer/upgrade issues. * FlaggedRevisions and the new AbuseFilter extension have continued to see maintenance development from contract developers Aaron and Andrew. * Kul Wadhwa and Tomasz began assessing a lead on sponsorship of development time and hardware for improved reliability of database dump generation. In the meantime Tomasz will coordinate with external partners on partial or complete Commons/Wikimedia file mirroring. * Summer of Code student applications were received and four projects accepted.
The focus of the usability team in April was to review and analyze the findings from the usability study. After the team completed its initial analysis, Naoko Komura released the study's methodology and findings to the public project site. (usability.wikimedia.org) The team began to brainstorm solutions to problem areas revealed during the initial data collection, and conducted an environmental scan of available extensions and tools potentially related to usability.
OTHER PROGRAM ACTIVITIES
On April 12, the Wikimedia Foundation launched a community vote on whether to adopt Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike as the primary license for all eligible GFDL-licensed content. The vote will be concluded in May. (For this purpose, a new MediaWiki software extension, SecurePoll, was developed, which will be refined further as a general-purpose extension for secure elections and polls.) The vote was administered by Software in the Public Interest (SPI), a non-profit organization which aims to help develop and distribute open hardware and software. SPI also administers the Wikimedia Foundation's Board of Trustees elections process.
On April 13, the Wikimedia Foundation welcomed Jennifer Riggs as its first-ever Chief Program Officer, and Jennifer began orienting herself to the work and culture of the Foundation. Jennifer comes to Wikimedia from the American Red Cross Bay Area chapter, where, as Manager of Volunteer Resources, she managed the work of more than a thousand volunteers. Prior to the Red Cross, she worked at the California School-Age Consortium and with the Peace Corps. Jennifer's orientation will include numerous informal discussions with Wikimedia volunteers as well as Advisory Board members.
Cary Bass and Sara Crouse worked with Wikimedia volunteers to launch the Wikimania scholarship application process.
The Wikimedia Foundation participated in interviews with KNX/CBS 1070 Radio (Los Angeles, California); National Public Radio (Seattle, Washington); VEJA Magazine (Sao Paulo, Brazil); the Wall Street Journal (San Francisco, California); Les Echos (Paris, France); Gazeta Wyborcza (Warsaw, Poland); Cinco Dias (Madrid, Spain); Creativity Magazine (New York, New York); Symbol Report (Frederick, Maryland); Telephony (Chicago, Illinois); the Associated Press (New York, New York); MediaPost (New York, New York); and the Times newspaper (London, United Kingdom).
FUNDRAISING, GRANTS, & PARTNERSHIPS
During April, the Wikimedia Foundation received 922 donations, with a combined total value of USD 78,453. Year-to-date, the Wikimedia Foundation has raised USD 5,491415 in donations from individuals, 37% above the full-year target of USD 4,000,000.
Rebecca Handler organized a trip for herself and Sue Gardner to cultivate current and prospective donors in New York City in mid-May.
Rand Montoya continued planning for the Annual Giving Campaign as well as longer term community giving activities, and began work with Four Kitchens on upgrades to the open source CiviCRM donations database, including improved reporting functionality based on best practices in fundraising.
FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION
Work continued on the 2009-10 Annual Plan, including planning by all departments. Following Board review and approval of the 2008-09 Form 990 Tax Return, Veronique Kessler filed the return and posted a public copy of the return and an FAQ to the Wikimedia Foundation website (http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Form_2007_Questions_and_Answers). Veronique also began researching the implications of the Wikimedia Foundation beginning to offer grants to individuals and chapter organizations, and Veronique and Jennifer began creating draft procedures related to approving grants.
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
After several months of negotiations, Business Development executed its first major strategic partnership with a Fortune 500 company. This is a mission-friendly three-year deal with Orange (France Telecom) to integrate Wikipedia content and marks into Orange's web and mobile properties. http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Press_releases/Orange_and_Wikimedia_anno...
Future developments may include improving mobile functionality, new applications, expansion to IPTV and other platforms.
LEGAL
At the April Board meeting, Sue presented a position paper outlining recommendations for the handling and development of the Foundation's commercially valuable trademarks. The paper was developed by Mike Godwin with co-authors John Slafsky and Nathan Ferguson of the law firm Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Rosati. Following its review, the Board requested that Mike take appropriate steps to register and protect the Wikimedia marks, and also develop a strategy, policies and practices, to allow uses by the chapters and community for activities in line with the Wikimedia mission. Following the Board meeting, Mike distributed a first-draft policy to the chapters, and began collecting feedback.
2009/8/11 Sue Gardner sgardner@wikimedia.org:
FUNDRAISING, GRANTS, & PARTNERSHIPS
During April, the Wikimedia Foundation received 922 donations, with a combined total value of USD 78,453. Year-to-date, the Wikimedia Foundation has raised USD 5,491415 in donations from individuals, 37% above the full-year target of USD 4,000,000.
As always, thanks for these reports. I'm curious - 37% is a lot of extra money, is there a plan for how to spend it? Has this year's spending been increased or will the extra just be carried over to next year or just kept as reserves?
2009/8/11 Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com:
2009/8/11 Sue Gardner sgardner@wikimedia.org:
FUNDRAISING, GRANTS, & PARTNERSHIPS
During April, the Wikimedia Foundation received 922 donations, with a combined total value of USD 78,453. Year-to-date, the Wikimedia Foundation has raised USD 5,491415 in donations from individuals, 37% above the full-year target of USD 4,000,000.
As always, thanks for these reports. I'm curious - 37% is a lot of extra money, is there a plan for how to spend it? Has this year's spending been increased or will the extra just be carried over to next year or just kept as reserves?
As always, you are hugely welcome -- it's my pleasure :-)
I will ask Veronique to reply a little more fully, but here's the gist:
1) That paragraph of the report doesn't cover our full financial picture -- total revenues weren't up 37%, just individual donations as a subset of total revenues. So, there was not a USD 1.49 million "surplus" -- it was less than that, because other areas under-performed against plan in the same period. Also bear in mind that spending varied relative to plan, as well.
2) #1 notwithstanding, we are indeed thinking about what to do with money unspent in a given year. In general, I do not want the Wikimedia Foundation to accumulate massive reserves -- generally, because donors give money in hopes it will be spent usefully. But at the same time, it would be imprudent to have no financial cushion at all. This is one of the issues Veronique and I think about quite a bit, and I know she is hoping that the strategy project will work on it too. How much reserve is enough, when is it time to build towards an endowment.
I'll ask Veronique to comment further :-)
Thanks, Sue
Your comment is very timely. We are, and have been, thinking about the best solution regarding extra money. First, we want to consider an appropriate "reserve" amount, i.e. this can range from 3 months of expenses for some organizations to 2 years for others. So, we are discussing this; there are lots of theories of the perfect amount. Beyond that, we are considering things like investment strategy, the creation of an endowment, etc.-things that can help towards ongoing financial sustainability.
Veronique
Thomas Dalton wrote:
2009/8/11 Sue Gardner sgardner@wikimedia.org:
FUNDRAISING, GRANTS, & PARTNERSHIPS
During April, the Wikimedia Foundation received 922 donations, with a combined total value of USD 78,453. Year-to-date, the Wikimedia Foundation has raised USD 5,491415 in donations from individuals, 37% above the full-year target of USD 4,000,000.
As always, thanks for these reports. I'm curious - 37% is a lot of extra money, is there a plan for how to spend it? Has this year's spending been increased or will the extra just be carried over to next year or just kept as reserves?
foundation-l mailing list foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
2009/8/12 Veronique Kessler vkessler@wikimedia.org:
Your comment is very timely. We are, and have been, thinking about the best solution regarding extra money. First, we want to consider an appropriate "reserve" amount, i.e. this can range from 3 months of expenses for some organizations to 2 years for others. So, we are discussing this; there are lots of theories of the perfect amount. Beyond that, we are considering things like investment strategy, the creation of an endowment, etc.-things that can help towards ongoing financial sustainability.
Thank you both for your replies. I drafted a Reserve Policy for Wikimedia UK so I have some idea of the challenge facing you there! I'm really glad you are giving the subject of an endowment serious thought, I think it would be really good to have that kind of sustainability in the future.
I want to echo Thomas's remarks. It is certainly a fine line to balance, and I am glad that the donor's concerns are on your mind. I also want to reiterate my support for an endowment. I'm not going to preach at anyone here (least of all you and Veronique) the benefits of having one, but I'm glad that it is actively on the WMF staff's mind.
-Dan On Aug 11, 2009, at 8:29 PM, Thomas Dalton wrote:
2009/8/12 Veronique Kessler vkessler@wikimedia.org:
Your comment is very timely. We are, and have been, thinking about the best solution regarding extra money. First, we want to consider an appropriate "reserve" amount, i.e. this can range from 3 months of expenses for some organizations to 2 years for others. So, we are discussing this; there are lots of theories of the perfect amount. Beyond that, we are considering things like investment strategy, the creation of an endowment, etc.-things that can help towards ongoing financial sustainability.
Thank you both for your replies. I drafted a Reserve Policy for Wikimedia UK so I have some idea of the challenge facing you there! I'm really glad you are giving the subject of an endowment serious thought, I think it would be really good to have that kind of sustainability in the future.
foundation-l mailing list foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
Hi Thomas and others following this thread,
I am following up with a more detailed response. Since the Board report was for the month of April, but our fiscal year ended June 30, I'd like to re-cap the fiscal year's results for the operating budget.
The plan for 2008-09 called for $7.3 million of revenue and $5.9 million in expenses which would have resulted in a reserve of $1.4 million. Our current estimate (we are still closing up the books) are that we will have revenue of $7.7 million and expenses of $5.2 million which will result in a reserve of $2.5 million. This is good news, but at the beginning of the last online fundraiser, back in October and November 2008, it looked like we might not make our target for community gifts which was $3 million for the entire year (much of it concentrated from October through January). Thanks to a few different factors and the personal appeal from Jimmy, the situation turned around and we found not only that community gifts would well exceed the $3 million, they would be the largest source of revenue for the 2008-09 fiscal year and would help make up for shortfalls in other revenue areas.
Meanwhile, our expenses were lower than plan because we slowed spending and stopped some spending altogether from October to January. This was in response to both the global economic crisis and concerns that donations might be impacted significantly by the crisis.
Instead, we had a strong year and now have the task of making the best decisions regarding reserve amounts. As Sue said, we can't and do not want to continually grow reserves as donors like to see their money going towards productive work. At the same time, we want to have a certain level of security that when unforeseen events occur, we can be confident that we can keep the servers running, keep the lights on and all will be well with Wikimedia's projects.
Feel free to email with other questions,
Veronique
Thomas Dalton wrote:
2009/8/12 Veronique Kessler vkessler@wikimedia.org:
Your comment is very timely. We are, and have been, thinking about the best solution regarding extra money. First, we want to consider an appropriate "reserve" amount, i.e. this can range from 3 months of expenses for some organizations to 2 years for others. So, we are discussing this; there are lots of theories of the perfect amount. Beyond that, we are considering things like investment strategy, the creation of an endowment, etc.-things that can help towards ongoing financial sustainability.
Thank you both for your replies. I drafted a Reserve Policy for Wikimedia UK so I have some idea of the challenge facing you there! I'm really glad you are giving the subject of an endowment serious thought, I think it would be really good to have that kind of sustainability in the future.
foundation-l mailing list foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
On Tue, Aug 11, 2009 at 6:46 PM, Sue Gardner sgardner@wikimedia.org wrote:
Report to the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
Covering: April 2009 Prepared by: Sue Gardner, Executive Director, Wikimedia Foundation Prepared for: Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
I really like these reports, but they'd be more useful if they came sooner after the events they describe. Will you be able to catch up to a <1-month delay in the near future? (I wouldn't mind if the reports for May, June, and July were condensed, if that's what it took.)
2009/8/12 Benjamin Lees emufarmers@gmail.com:
On Tue, Aug 11, 2009 at 6:46 PM, Sue Gardner sgardner@wikimedia.org wrote:
Report to the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
Covering: April 2009 Prepared by: Sue Gardner, Executive Director, Wikimedia Foundation Prepared for: Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees
I really like these reports, but they'd be more useful if they came sooner after the events they describe. Will you be able to catch up to a <1-month delay in the near future? (I wouldn't mind if the reports for May, June, and July were condensed, if that's what it took.)
Yes, I've been thinking that. Do we get the reports at about the same time as the board or is the delay due to the need to go through the report checking if anything needs to be redacted? I wouldn't mind combined reports either, but they aren't really meant for us, it's what the board wants that is most important.
Thomas Dalton wrote:
2009/8/12 Benjamin Lees emufarmers@gmail.com:
I really like these reports, but they'd be more useful if they came sooner after the events they describe. Will you be able to catch up to a <1-month delay in the near future? (I wouldn't mind if the reports for May, June, and July were condensed, if that's what it took.)
Yes, I've been thinking that. Do we get the reports at about the same time as the board or is the delay due to the need to go through the report checking if anything needs to be redacted?
The delay tends to be minimal, Sue typically sends information to the community directly after having communicated with the board, although occasionally a portion of a report may be redacted. In this case, the board received the April report yesterday. It was actually out of sequence, because we received her report for May a little earlier, so I expect you should see that one pretty soon as well. As for getting fully caught up, I'm sure that's her goal, although you may appreciate that at times actually doing the work ends up taking priority over reporting on the work that was done. From the board's perspective, she does keep us informed of developments outside the monthly reports as well, so we remain able to exercise our oversight responsibilities, but I would agree that these monthly summaries are very helpful.
--Michael Snow
wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org