The community proposal to host the regional [SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards,Pankaj
+1 to this.
DR English Wikipedia
On Tue, 24 Mar 2026 at 9:37 PM, Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj _______________________________________________ Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
In my view, the Wikimedia Foundation tends to say that the South Asian volunteer user community manages itself, while the regional volunteer user community tends to say that Wikimedia Foundation staff make the regional Wikimedia governance decisions.
Whatever the reality is, I wish that we could have open conversations about roles and responsibilities of WMF staff versus volunteer organizations. This is a recurring issue over 10+ years in every region of the world.
On Wed, Mar 25, 2026 at 11:33 AM DR Wikipedia via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
+1 to this.
DR English Wikipedia
On Tue, 24 Mar 2026 at 9:37 PM, Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj _______________________________________________ Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Hi all.
The same situation was with our attempt to organize Central Asian Wikicon 2026. While 2025 edition (first one) was a huge success for a developing Wikimedia region with several small communities, 2026 one was called an overlap with no real alternative (CEE doesn’t fully include Central Asian communities only doing a favour because they were part of the USSR in the past, ESEAP and South Asian events don’t include Central Asia at all). It’s a bit surprising to see that somewhere events are overlapping, not mentioning the scale of that overlap.
Вторник, 24 марта 2026, 21:07 +05:00 от Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l <wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org
:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal ( https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun... ) was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l
Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/...
To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
-- С уважением, Николай.
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the [SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference." Additionally, we were advised that "Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "an iteration of a recurring event." But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been [discussion on the talk page](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) about the proposal previously being framed as a "Wikimedia Technical Summit" before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of close connection between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of [Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Con...) and [WikiConference India 2025](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Con...) had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied across different proposals ? - Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? - What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional [SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards,Pankaj
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Hello,
While I have limited knowledge of the specific conferences being discussed in this thread, I would be interested in seeing a review of how conferences are planned and funded in general. Also, I wonder if it would be possible to link the affiliate strategy review ( https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Updating_the_ecosystem_of_Wikimedia_organiza...) and the Global Resource Distribution Committee's activities ( https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Global_Resource_Distribution_Committee) with a review of events strategy. I am concerned that with seemingly so many events happening, that a lot of time and money may be spent on numerous smaller events that could be more effectively spent on fewer and larger events. See also the recent issue with demand for Wikimania tickets exceeding supply, and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Talk:Wikimedia_Foundation_Annual_Plan/2026-2.... I plan to follow up on the general issue of events strategy under that "Reducing event costs" discussion. Other people in this thread may also wish to comment on the Annual Plan talk page with any issues that they think should be brought into scope for work during the 2026-2027 Annual Plan.
Pine🌲
On Mon, Apr 20, 2026 at 10:31 PM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was shared on wiki, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026#c-CKibelka_(WMF)-20250319155900-Decision_on_the_Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026_proposal the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the Conference Committee https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found here on meta-wiki https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements .
There are some basic eligibility criteria https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all recent proposals https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications# on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
*Belinda Mbambo* Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications Wikimedia Foundation https://wikimediafoundation.org/
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. Below is the content from that email, which I believe highlights critical gaps in communication:
Content of Previous Email (18th April)
Dear Belinda,
Thank you for your Email response
I would like to clarify that while the rejection itself is disappointing, the primary concern for us lies in the responses our community received from the Committee on our proposal talk page. In February, we received a set of questions, to which we promptly responded with detailed answers within the following week. However, when the decision was communicated to us in March, it seemed to focus primarily on the close connection between WikiConference India and the potential SAARC Conference, citing uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India as a key factor.
We are still struggling to understand why this issue led to the rejection of our proposal, especially considering the context surrounding India. You mentioned that multiple factors are considered when evaluating proposals. However, based on the feedback we received, the main concern raised by the Committee was the connection between WikiConference India and the SAARC Conference, tied to the uncertain situations in India. After discussing this with some community members, this leads us to ask: Why was this issue only highlighted when it came from a volunteer community like ours and not when it involved an institutional body in India? Why do we feel that the Committee treated us differently?
Further Concerns and Questions:
- How can we resolve issues that are specific to India (such as the FCRA license) from Nepal? This seems outside of our control. Why should our proposal be impacted by challenges in another country? - The Open Knowledge Conference proposal on the talk page has unanswered questions, despite being months since they were posted. Did the Committee have time to review and respond to these before approval? Or was this simply overlooked? - We feel that the lack of transparency in the process, especially for smaller volunteer communities like ours, is a significant concern. You mentioned that we might not be aware of behind-the-scenes discussions. But isn’t it important to ensure that all voices—especially those of volunteers—are heard clearly and fairly?
We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj On Wednesday, April 22nd, 2026 at 12:30 AM, Belinda Mbambo via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was [shared on wiki,](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the [Conference Committee](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee) who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found [here on meta-wiki](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirement...).
There are some basic [eligibility criteria](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirement...) to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all [recent proposals](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications#) on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
Belinda Mbambo Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications [Wikimedia Foundation](https://wikimediafoundation.org/)
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the [SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference." Additionally, we were advised that "Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "an iteration of a recurring event." But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been [discussion on the talk page](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) about the proposal previously being framed as a "Wikimedia Technical Summit" before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of close connection between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of [Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Con...) and [WikiConference India 2025](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Con...) had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied across different proposals ?
- Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.?
- What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional [SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards,Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Hello Pankaj Sharma Ji,
I’m writing in response to your recent posts across multiple mailing lists, including WikimediaIndia-l.
First, I want to acknowledge a lapse on my part: I should have communicated the reason for moderating (not approving) your message. As a moderator, it is my standard practice to provide such context, and I regret not doing so in this instance.
With that, I would like to clarify the decision itself. The message was not approved because it had already been sent to multiple mailing lists with largely the same content, and it did not add new or list-specific information for WikimediaIndia-l. In moderation, we try to ensure that discussions remain relevant, constructive, and non-duplicative for the specific audience of each list.
This decision was not a judgment on the importance of the broader concerns you are raising, but rather on the suitability of that particular message for this specific mailing list, given its repetition and lack of additional context tailored to the audience.
Going forward, I encourage you to:
-
Share list-specific context when cross-posting -
Consolidate follow-ups where possible instead of repeating similar messages -
Clearly distinguish new information or developments in subsequent posts
I appreciate your understanding, and I remain open to constructive, focused discussions on the list.
Regards,
Chinmayee
On Thu, Apr 30, 2026 at 10:25 AM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
- "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close
connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. Below is the content from that email, which I believe highlights critical gaps in communication:
*Content of Previous Email (18th April)*
*Dear Belinda,*
*Thank you for your Email response*
*I would like to clarify that while the rejection itself is disappointing, the primary concern for us lies in the responses our community received from the Committee on our proposal talk page. In February, we received a set of questions, to which we promptly responded with detailed answers within the following week. However, when the decision was communicated to us in March, it seemed to focus primarily on the close connection between WikiConference India and the potential SAARC Conference, citing uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India as a key factor.*
*We are still struggling to understand why this issue led to the rejection of our proposal, especially considering the context surrounding India. You mentioned that multiple factors are considered when evaluating proposals. However, based on the feedback we received, the main concern raised by the Committee was the connection between WikiConference India and the SAARC Conference, tied to the uncertain situations in India. After discussing this with some community members, this leads us to ask: Why was this issue only highlighted when it came from a volunteer community like ours and not when it involved an institutional body in India? Why do we feel that the Committee treated us differently?*
*Further Concerns and Questions:*
- *How can we resolve issues that are specific to India (such as the
FCRA license) from Nepal? This seems outside of our control. Why should our proposal be impacted by challenges in another country?* 2. *The Open Knowledge Conference proposal on the talk page has unanswered questions, despite being months since they were posted. Did the Committee have time to review and respond to these before approval? Or was this simply overlooked?* 3. *We feel that the lack of transparency in the process, especially for smaller volunteer communities like ours, is a significant concern. You mentioned that we might not be aware of behind-the-scenes discussions. But isn’t it important to ensure that all voices—especially those of volunteers—are heard clearly and fairly?*
We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj On Wednesday, April 22nd, 2026 at 12:30 AM, Belinda Mbambo via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was shared on wiki, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026#c-CKibelka_(WMF)-20250319155900-Decision_on_the_Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026_proposal the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the Conference Committee https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found here on meta-wiki https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements .
There are some basic eligibility criteria https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all recent proposals https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications# on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
*Belinda Mbambo* Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications Wikimedia Foundation https://wikimediafoundation.org/
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj
On Tuesday, April 21st, 2026 at 8:49 PM, Belinda Mbambo via WikimediaIndia-l wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was [shared on wiki,](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the [Conference Committee](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee) who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found [here on meta-wiki](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirement...).
There are some basic [eligibility criteria](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirement...) to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all [recent proposals](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications#) on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
Belinda Mbambo Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications [Wikimedia Foundation](https://wikimediafoundation.org/)
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the [SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference." Additionally, we were advised that "Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "an iteration of a recurring event." But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been [discussion on the talk page](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) about the proposal previously being framed as a "Wikimedia Technical Summit" before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of close connection between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of [Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Con...) and [WikiConference India 2025](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Con...) had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied across different proposals ?
- Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.?
- What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional [SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal](https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fun...) was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards,Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Dear all, Over the past few months, there has been increased activity from IIIT Hyderabad’s Open Knowledge Initiatives (OKI) team within Indic Wikimedia communities, along with conversations around upcoming conferences. We wanted to share the context to help situate these developments. The increased engagement from IIIT Hyderabad with Indic Wikimedia communities follows the integration of the Open Knowledge Initiatives (OKI) team into IIIT Hyderabad, which now hosts multiple verticals of work related to open knowledge and Wikimedia projects across Indic languages. This expanded scope has naturally led to greater institutional activity and collaboration with communities. More details about the initiative and areas of work are available here: https://w.wiki/KtNL We also wanted to clarify that WikiConference India 2026 (WCI 2026), and the Open Knowledge Conference are distinct in both structure and purpose. WikiConference India 2026 is envisioned as a community-led, capacity-building space for Wikimedia contributors, affiliates, and partners across India and South Asia, with volunteer committees guiding the process and includes regional participation . WCI 2026 is supported by IIIT Hyderabad and the Open Knowledge Conference is being designed as a strategic forum to connect research, practice, and emerging movement-wide challenges, including sustainability, contributor retention, and responsible technology integration. There is a participation paradox along with other trends like evolving relationships with Legacy knowledge authorities and a fragmenting consensus on "facts," the Open Knowledge Conference aims to develop actionable, research-informed strategies to address these trends across Global Majority communities, while addressing emergent movement relevant trends While the two conferences may appear close in timing, they serve different audiences and objectives. Additionally, India has hosted relatively few national-level Wikimedia conferences over the past decade and a half, and this surge of activity reflects renewed momentum rather than a recurring pattern. It is also worth noting that the Open Knowledge Conference is tentatively scheduled for the later months of 2026 and the timelines are still being finalised. We hope this context is helpful. We look forward to continued collaboration and shared learning across communities. Best regards, Pavan Santhosh, Program Manager, Open Knowledge Initiatives at RCTS, IIIT-Hyderabad. ________________________________ పంపినవారు: Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org పంపినవి: 30, ఏప్రిల్ 2026, గురువారం 11:04 AM గ్రహీత: Masum al Hasan masum.ru.apee@gmail.com; Belinda Mbambo bmbambo@wikimedia.org Cc: Wikimedia India Community list wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org; Wikimedia Mailing List wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org; wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org; wikipedia-ne@lists.wikimedia.org wikipedia-ne@lists.wikimedia.org; Pankaj Sharma Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com విషయం: [Wikimedia-l] Re: [WikimediaIndia-l] Re: Re: Why Was Nepal Denied While Overlapping Grants Were Approved in India?
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj
On Tuesday, April 21st, 2026 at 8:49 PM, Belinda Mbambo via WikimediaIndia-l wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was shared on wiki,https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026#c-CKibelka_(WMF)-20250319155900-Decision_on_the_Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026_proposal the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the Conference Committeehttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found here on meta-wikihttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements.
There are some basic eligibility criteriahttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all recent proposalshttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications# on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
[https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/Fu6ujnrrEMNkZniwgLYiO93yoa7AmhNsA9PV0GkMmR...] Belinda Mbambo Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications Wikimedia Foundationhttps://wikimediafoundation.org/
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l <wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.orgmailto:wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote: Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l <wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.orgmailto:wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote: Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference." Additionally, we were advised that "Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "an iteration of a recurring event." But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk pagehttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "Wikimedia Technical Summit" before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of close connection between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
1. How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma <Pankajsharma96@protonmail.commailto:Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote: The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepalhttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
_______________________________________________ Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.orgmailto:wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.orgmailto:wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org _______________________________________________ Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.orgmailto:wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.orgmailto:wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Any Payments available
On Fri, 1 May 2026, 10:54 pm Pavan Santhosh via Wikimedia-l, < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Dear all, Over the past few months, there has been increased activity from IIIT Hyderabad’s Open Knowledge Initiatives (OKI) team within Indic Wikimedia communities, along with conversations around upcoming conferences. We wanted to share the context to help situate these developments.
The increased engagement from IIIT Hyderabad with Indic Wikimedia communities follows the integration of the Open Knowledge Initiatives (OKI) team into IIIT Hyderabad, which now hosts multiple verticals of work related to open knowledge and Wikimedia projects across Indic languages. This expanded scope has naturally led to greater institutional activity and collaboration with communities. More details about the initiative and areas of work are available here: *https://w.wiki/KtNL* https://w.wiki/KtNL We also wanted to clarify that WikiConference India 2026 (WCI 2026), and the Open Knowledge Conference are distinct in both structure and purpose. WikiConference India 2026 is envisioned as a community-led, capacity-building space for Wikimedia contributors, affiliates, and partners across India and South Asia, with volunteer committees guiding the process and includes regional participation . WCI 2026 is supported by IIIT Hyderabad and the Open Knowledge Conference is being designed as a strategic forum to connect research, practice, and emerging movement-wide challenges, including sustainability, contributor retention, and responsible technology integration. There is a participation paradox along with other trends like evolving relationships with Legacy knowledge authorities and a fragmenting consensus on "facts," the Open Knowledge Conference aims to develop actionable, research-informed strategies to address these trends across Global Majority communities, while addressing emergent movement relevant trends While the two conferences may appear close in timing, they serve different audiences and objectives. Additionally, India has hosted relatively few national-level Wikimedia conferences over the past decade and a half, and this surge of activity reflects renewed momentum rather than a recurring pattern. It is also worth noting that the Open Knowledge Conference is tentatively scheduled for the later months of 2026 and the timelines are still being finalised. We hope this context is helpful. We look forward to continued collaboration and shared learning across communities. Best regards, Pavan Santhosh, Program Manager, Open Knowledge Initiatives at RCTS, IIIT-Hyderabad.
*పంపినవారు:* Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> *పంపినవి:* 30, ఏప్రిల్ 2026, గురువారం 11:04 AM *గ్రహీత:* Masum al Hasan masum.ru.apee@gmail.com; Belinda Mbambo < bmbambo@wikimedia.org> *Cc:* Wikimedia India Community list wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org; Wikimedia Mailing List wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org; wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org; wikipedia-ne@lists.wikimedia.org wikipedia-ne@lists.wikimedia.org; Pankaj Sharma Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com *విషయం:* [Wikimedia-l] Re: [WikimediaIndia-l] Re: Re: Why Was Nepal Denied While Overlapping Grants Were Approved in India?
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
- "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close
connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj
On Tuesday, April 21st, 2026 at 8:49 PM, Belinda Mbambo via WikimediaIndia-l wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was shared on wiki, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026#c-CKibelka_(WMF)-20250319155900-Decision_on_the_Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026_proposal the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the Conference Committee https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found here on meta-wiki https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements .
There are some basic eligibility criteria https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all recent proposals https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications# on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
*Belinda Mbambo* Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications Wikimedia Foundation https://wikimediafoundation.org/
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Hello Pavan,
Thank you for sharing this information. We strongly believe that IIIT Hyderabad has tremendous potential to advance the open knowledge mission across South Asia.
We look forward to further strengthening the Wikimedia movement in India and the broader South Asian region.
Best, Sai Founder & CEO Boli Cheto Foundation
On Sat, 2 May, 2026, 6:09 am SantoshPavanKumar Alla via Wikimedia-l, < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Any Payments available
On Fri, 1 May 2026, 10:54 pm Pavan Santhosh via Wikimedia-l, < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Dear all, Over the past few months, there has been increased activity from IIIT Hyderabad’s Open Knowledge Initiatives (OKI) team within Indic Wikimedia communities, along with conversations around upcoming conferences. We wanted to share the context to help situate these developments.
The increased engagement from IIIT Hyderabad with Indic Wikimedia communities follows the integration of the Open Knowledge Initiatives (OKI) team into IIIT Hyderabad, which now hosts multiple verticals of work related to open knowledge and Wikimedia projects across Indic languages. This expanded scope has naturally led to greater institutional activity and collaboration with communities. More details about the initiative and areas of work are available here: *https://w.wiki/KtNL* https://w.wiki/KtNL We also wanted to clarify that WikiConference India 2026 (WCI 2026), and the Open Knowledge Conference are distinct in both structure and purpose. WikiConference India 2026 is envisioned as a community-led, capacity-building space for Wikimedia contributors, affiliates, and partners across India and South Asia, with volunteer committees guiding the process and includes regional participation . WCI 2026 is supported by IIIT Hyderabad and the Open Knowledge Conference is being designed as a strategic forum to connect research, practice, and emerging movement-wide challenges, including sustainability, contributor retention, and responsible technology integration. There is a participation paradox along with other trends like evolving relationships with Legacy knowledge authorities and a fragmenting consensus on "facts," the Open Knowledge Conference aims to develop actionable, research-informed strategies to address these trends across Global Majority communities, while addressing emergent movement relevant trends While the two conferences may appear close in timing, they serve different audiences and objectives. Additionally, India has hosted relatively few national-level Wikimedia conferences over the past decade and a half, and this surge of activity reflects renewed momentum rather than a recurring pattern. It is also worth noting that the Open Knowledge Conference is tentatively scheduled for the later months of 2026 and the timelines are still being finalised. We hope this context is helpful. We look forward to continued collaboration and shared learning across communities. Best regards, Pavan Santhosh, Program Manager, Open Knowledge Initiatives at RCTS, IIIT-Hyderabad.
*పంపినవారు:* Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> *పంపినవి:* 30, ఏప్రిల్ 2026, గురువారం 11:04 AM *గ్రహీత:* Masum al Hasan masum.ru.apee@gmail.com; Belinda Mbambo < bmbambo@wikimedia.org> *Cc:* Wikimedia India Community list < wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org>; Wikimedia Mailing List < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org>; wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org < wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org>; wikipedia-ne@lists.wikimedia.org < wikipedia-ne@lists.wikimedia.org>; Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> *విషయం:* [Wikimedia-l] Re: [WikimediaIndia-l] Re: Re: Why Was Nepal Denied While Overlapping Grants Were Approved in India?
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
- "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close
connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj
On Tuesday, April 21st, 2026 at 8:49 PM, Belinda Mbambo via WikimediaIndia-l wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was shared on wiki, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026#c-CKibelka_(WMF)-20250319155900-Decision_on_the_Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026_proposal the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the Conference Committee https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found here on meta-wiki https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements .
There are some basic eligibility criteria https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all recent proposals https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications# on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
*Belinda Mbambo* Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications Wikimedia Foundation https://wikimediafoundation.org/
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Dear Belinda, Pankaj Sharma, and Wikimedia community members, Greetings from Maithili Wikimedians User Group.
We have followed the recent discussion regarding the Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 proposal, the concerns raised on the Wikimedia mailing lists, and the responses shared by community members and Wikimedia Foundation representatives.
At the outset, we would like to clarify an important point: Pankaj Sharma is not associated with Maithili Wikimedians User Group and does not represent Maithili Wikimedians User Group in any official capacity. Any comments, questions, or concerns shared by him in this thread should be understood as his personal views and not as an official position of Maithili Wikimedians User Group.
Maithili Wikimedians User Group respects the openness of Wikimedia mailing lists and the right of individual Wikimedians to raise questions in community spaces. However, we also believe it is important to avoid confusion regarding organizational representation, especially when discussions involve grant proposals, regional conferences, institutional accountability, and community decision-making processes.
Our group remains committed to constructive engagement with the Wikimedia Foundation, the Conference Fund Committee, South Asian Wikimedia communities, and the broader movement. While the rejection of the SAARC Conference proposal was naturally disappointing, we value transparent dialogue and remain open to learning from the feedback received. We are also committed to strengthening our organizational capacity, improving future proposals, and contributing positively to regional collaboration in South Asia.
We kindly request all participants in this discussion to distinguish between individual opinions and official communication from Maithili Wikimedians User Group. Any official statement from our group will be shared through authorized representatives or official communication channels of the User Group.
We appreciate the encouragement and constructive comments shared by community members and look forward to continuing meaningful collaboration for the growth of Wikimedia communities in Nepal, Maithili-language projects, and the wider South Asian region.
Regards, Pankaj Kumar Deo Chair Maithili Wikimedians User Group
On Thu, 30 Apr 2026, 14:10 Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l, < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
I appreciate your kind words Rocky, and I understand the spirit behind your encouragement. However we as a community feel compelled to express some concerns that continue to weigh heavily on us.
While your message acknowledges the effort we’ve put into the proposal, I want to be clear that the discouragement comes not just from the rejection, but from the lack of transparency and fairness in the decision-making process. As you rightly mentioned, many regions already have established conferences, but South Asia is still in the early stages. That's exactly why our proposed SAARC Conference was so important.
The last SAARC conference was held in 2019 organized by CIS, but since then no initiatives have been taken to host another one. When our community finally took the step to revive this effort, the proposal was rejected. The main reason cited by the committee was:
- "One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close
connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference. Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
This reasoning raises several important questions, which I’ve also raised in my previous email. Why were we asked to solve the internal issues of an organization in India? We are just a volunteer-led community, not paid employees.
Additionally, our emails to the India mailing list have been rejected by some of the same people involved in the decision-making process. This gives the impression that discussion is being suppressed, and that the voices of the volunteer community are being ignored. It feels like the foundation is preventing these critical issues from being discussed with the broader community.
Belinda, as I mentioned before, I shared a set of questions regarding transparency and clarifications in an email on 18th April. Unfortunately I have not yet received any responses. We hope Belinda, you will respond to these questions on this email.
Furthermore, we have come to know that CIS is now the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. What surprised us even more is that the director board members for both organizations are the same. Is there a potential conflict of interest or undue influence in how proposals from these institutions are being evaluated?
We have also observed that proposals with institutional backing seem to receive faster approval and less scrutiny than others, despite having similar goals and target audiences. A recent example is the renamed Open Knowledge Conference, which was approved with minimal questioning and without addressing the concerns raised by the community.
This is particularly striking considering that the grantees of this event have close ties to the Wikimedia Foundation, with some having previously served as grant officers at Wikimedia Foundation. It raises important questions about the evaluation process and whether such prior relationships might be influencing the way proposals are reviewed. If these relationships are playing a role, it could result in a situation where proposals from institutional bodies are approved quickly and with less scrutiny, while volunteer-led proposals like ours face more stringent questioning.
We believe that these issues need to be addressed in order to ensure a fair future for all proposals, regardless of whether they are led by volunteers or institutions.
We look forward to hearing your responses to these concerns and to understanding the rationale behind these decisions.
Pankaj
On Tuesday, April 21st, 2026 at 8:49 PM, Belinda Mbambo via WikimediaIndia-l wikimediaindia-l@lists.wikimedia.org wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
Replying here in addition to the conversation you started directly with us.
We understand a rejection of any proposal is a disappointing outcome and we work with a certain set of criterias, processes and resources. As was shared on wiki, https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026#c-CKibelka_(WMF)-20250319155900-Decision_on_the_Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026_proposal the conference committee - made up of Wikimedians - did not approve the conference for a range of reasons.
We work closely with the Conference Committee https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference_Grants/Committee who, together with inputs gathered from multiple discussions with the grantee, arrive at the funding conclusions. On the same pages you will find the timelines, stages, process and be able to review past proposals and reports.
It was suggested to build capacity and expertise of the team before scaling up to large regional events. This approach would better align with the Maithili Wikimedians’ track record in event organization and grant management.
I know others have also enquired about this process - more information can be found here on meta-wiki https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements .
There are some basic eligibility criteria https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/en#Eligibility_requirements to apply for a Conference Fund, we use these parameters to ensure funds are disbursed to those who have past experience with managing a large fund and/or conference, the past record, no pending reports and/or work with a Fiscal Sponsor who fulfills some of these requirements.
Furthermore, there are multiple factors that are considered (along with the above) which differ in each round (external situation, available resources, assessment of all submissions) and emerging community needs and strategy.
A rejection is always supported by suggestions on steps which could be taken to address any identified improvements, if applicable. You can find the responses to all recent proposals https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Conference/Browse_applications# on their talk page.
Best, Belinda
*Belinda Mbambo* Senior Manager: Global Movement Communications Wikimedia Foundation https://wikimediafoundation.org/
On Tue, Apr 21, 2026 at 7:31 AM Masum al Hasan via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Pankaj,
I understand that the outcome must be disappointing, especially after the effort invested in preparing the proposal. Please do not feel discouraged.
Many regions already have established regional conferences, and South Asia is still working toward that milestone. In that context, the initiative taken by the Maithili Wikimedia community is both significant and commendable. Even though the proposal was not funded this time, the effort itself carries substantial value.
I would like to sincerely appreciate the Maithili Wikimedians for taking this important first step. This should not be viewed as a failure, but rather as the beginning of a larger and more ambitious journey. Such initiatives often lay the groundwork for future success, and this effort will certainly be remembered as a pioneering one.
Best, Rocky
On Fri, Apr 3, 2026 at 4:46 PM Pankaj Sharma via Wikimedia-l < wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org> wrote:
Thank you Butch, Arvind, Николай, DR and Lane for the thoughtful responses and for sharing additional perspectives related to this matter. I would like to follow up to clarify a few points and to raise some concerns that remain unresolved from the earlier discussion.
Our community proposal to organize the SAARC Conference in Nepal for 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined, with one of the key reasons stated at talk page as: *"One of the main factors in the committee’s decision is the close connection between WikiConference India and a potential SAARC Conference."* Additionally, we were advised that *"Given the current uncertainties surrounding WikiConference India (due to the recently rejected FCRA license for CIS), the committee believes it would be best to focus on resolving that situation before considering funding for an additional large conference in the region."*
Our SAARC proposal was rejected due to uncertainties in India and concerns about overlap, it is surprising to observe that another proposal, Open Knowledge Conference was approved today without proper scrutiny, despite being closely related in scope, audience, and regional context. Our proposal had lot of questions asked for and the recent approved grant got approved surprisingly without any questions asked by the committee. Why for we volunteers there was lots of questioning but when the proposal is from a institutions under a staff role there is no question asked? This raises an important question about consistency in decision-making. We noticed in the committee's feedback that the Open Knowledge Conference is described as "*an iteration of a recurring event."* But we have been unable to identify previous editions of this event under the same name. At the same time there has been discussion on the talk page https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Open_Knowledge_Conference about the proposal previously being framed as a "*Wikimedia Technical Summit" *before being renamed. This raises an important question: if this is indeed a recurring event could the committee clarify under what name and format previous iterations were held? Additionally what was the rationale for the change in naming and how does this relate to the continuity being referenced in the evaluation ?
If the uncertainty around WikiConference in India and regulatory challenges were significant enough to halt our proposal entirely why were similar concerns not applied when evaluating proposals emerging from the same team at International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad? Is this difference in treatment influenced by the fact that our proposal led by the community volunteers, while proposals from the International Institute of Information Technology are being submitted in a staff or institutional capacity ?
The argument of *close connection* between events also appears to have been applied selectively. In our case it was a decisive reason for rejection. However in other instances where thematic and organizational overlap is evident, this concern does not seem to have been given the same weight.
This raises a fundamental question pointing:
*Why should our proposal be affected by regulatory or organizational problems in another country? **What about the close connection for proposal for WikiConference India 2026and Open Knowledge Conference?*
We want to share that the WikiConference India 2026 and the Open Knowledge Conference are scheduled within a span of approximately two months, while our rejected proposal of Wikimedia SAARC Conference 2026 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 and WikiConference India 2025 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/WikiConference_India_2025 had a gap of 10 months. Which one is here overlapping, SAARC or Open Knowledge Conference !
We note that Nepal was encouraged to scale down and build experience through smaller events. It is very much discouraging to see differing standards applied when other entities are getting multiple large-scale grants with overlapping goals and participants without any discussions or questions.
We respectfully ask to WMF and the community:
- How are overlap and regional connection being defined and applied
across different proposals ? 2. Why were external factors in one country used to delay or reject a proposal from another.? 3. What measures are in place to ensure equitable and consistent evaluation for both volunteer-led and staff-led proposals ?
Our community strongly believe that all communities regardless of size or geography should be given a fair opportunity to grow and contribute.
We request to have an committee to investigate all the previous and on-going grant proposals from this institution and make the process more transparent. We hope this can open a constructive and transparent dialogue toward greater accountability and consistency in decision-making process and allocation of funds to the communities.
Regards, Pankaj
On Tuesday, March 24th, 2026 at 3:18 AM, Pankaj Sharma < Pankajsharma96@protonmail.com> wrote:
The community proposal to host the regional SAARC Conference in 2026 in Nepal https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants_talk:Programs/Wikimedia_Community_Fund/Conference_Fund/Wikimedia_SAARC_Conference_2026 was declined. The reasons provided was the event would be redundant and an unnecessary expense because a similar conference is planned in India in the year of 2025. However in 2025 conference in India didn't happened and surprisingly our proposal was declined beacuse of that. But why.!!!
While Nepal’s proposal was viewed with skepticism regarding our capacity, the 2025 conference in India failed to materialize due to a failure in financial management and a lack of understanding regarding local FCRA regulations in India. This resulted in a substantial huge waste of Wikimedia Foundation resources. It is disheartening that the Conference Grant Program Officer applied Indian legal constraints as a blanket assumption for Nepal, hindering our community's growth based on a misunderstanding of our local context.
I have a question: How did the legal situation in India affect the decision on a proposal of Nepal?
Looking ahead to 2026 I was doubtful by the current grant applications from the International Institute of Information Technology Hyderabad. I see that a request for 207,000 USD has been submitted for WikiConference India 2026. Simultaneously, the same individual representing the same institution, has applied for an separate 87,554.81 USD for an Open Knowledge Conference within a gap of few months of the first event with same purpose and target participants.
As a Wikimedian this raises serious questions about the equitable distribution and potential misuse of community resources. While Nepal is told to scale down and gain experience with smaller events, a single institution is requesting nearly 300,000 USD for overlapping projects with same people in the organization role and same theme.
If the Wikimedia Foundation is concerned about redundancy and extra costs when it comes to Nepal, why is it being overlooked when a single institution in India applies for two major grants for nearly identical purposes? We need more accountability and a fairer distribution of resources to ensure that all communities not just one can grow. We urge the foundation and the community to investigate these for the benefit of the entire regional community and stop wasting the resources make the process more transparent and accountable.
Regards, Pankaj
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org, guidelines at: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l Public archives at https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org/... To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-l-leave@lists.wikimedia.org
wikimedia-l@lists.wikimedia.org