Hi
all,
I am writing to let you know that I am doing an auction with
Christie’s auction house, commencing today and closing on
December 15th.
We’re auctioning two things - the original Strawberry iMac that
I used during the founding time period of Wikipedia, and an NFT
artwork that I created to commemorate the earliest moment of
Wikipedia.
A bit of Q&A...
**What is an NFT?**
NFT stands for ‘non fungible token’, there is a fairly thorough
article about it on English Wikipedia
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-fungible_token>.
**What is this NFT exactly?**
I saw earlier in the year that Tim Berners-Lee did an NFT of
“the original source code of the web”. In his own words: “"I’m
selling a picture that I made, with a Python program that I
wrote myself, of what the source code would look like if it was
stuck on the wall and signed by me.”
I thought I should try to push forward from that and so instead
of just doing a picture (screenshot) of what Wikipedia looked
like when I first installed the Usemod software and typed
“Hello, World!” I would prefer to do something interactive.
The artistic concept is not just to see what Wikipedia looked
like to me in that moment, but to relive the experience: here is
this incredible vulnerable thing, a wiki, and you dream of it
becoming an encyclopedia for the whole world, but will it? Will
it be taken over by vandals and trolls instantly? What policies
will you need? What kind of community can you attract?
**Will any portion of the proceeds go to the WMF?**
The Wikimedia Foundation board has explicitly asked that I not
pledge any funds to Wikimedia. (They aren’t asking me not to
donate, just not to pledge to do so up front.) I am pledging to
donate to “help support a variety of charities working in the
free culture world.” I’ll decide after we see how it goes in
terms of what exactly I’ll do! (Advice welcome! I’d be
interested in a community process to help choose.)
I’ve worked with the WMF per the board’s instructions on getting
approval on all the marketing materials to make sure that it’s
clear that this is a personal project of mine and not a WMF
thing at all. I believe the WMF will also post about that.
**What about the environmental costs of creating an NFT?**
Ethereum is moving from 'Proof of Work' to 'Proof of Stake',
which requires a lot less energy per NFT - I’m happy to see that
and hope it happens soon.
In the meantime, I’ve looked for the highest estimate of the
amount of electricity consumed to mint an NFT. I’ve found an
estimate that the average NFT minting consumes 340kWh. For
scale, my friend has a Tesla Model X, and 340kWh would charge it
about 3 ½ times. This is roughly 81.6 kg of CO2. For further
comparison an economy-class ticket to NYC from London generates
about 1800 kilograms of CO2. (Citation needed, and very happy
for anyone with expertise to help me improve these
calculations.)
While I generally think it is better not to generate emissions
than to generate and offset, I also think that generating
withOUT offsetting is much worse. So I’ll be finding the most
pessimistic estimate of the CO2 that I’ve generated and offset
it by 5x.
** What is the estimate for the auction? **
Christie’s was unable to offer any public estimate for either
the computer or the NFT. I can sincerely say that I have
absolutely no idea what to expect. Given the current state of
the NFT market, I’m very hopeful that some crypto whale will
find this irresistible, who knows though?
I’ll be around for the next 8 hours or so to answer any
questions but to keep it all centralized, let’s keep it on my
English wikipedia talk page,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Jimbo_Wales
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Jimbo_Wales>
Article at Christie’s website here:
https://www.christies.com/features/First-Wikipedia-edit-to-be-sold-as-NFT-11983-1.aspx
<https://www.christies.com/features/First-Wikipedia-edit-to-be-sold-as-NFT-11983-1.aspx>