Am Freitag, 28. Dezember 2007 19:12:51 schrieb Gerard Meijssen:
[...] and the notion that an article without a sentence can be informative is impossible to you.
An encyclopedia article without a full sentence is indeed not able to be informative. I really don't want to discuss this trivial fact. Otherwise we will never get far.
. You are of the opinion that the Interwiki system is undermined by what you indicate as the Volapuk "articles" but you provide no arguments for this opinion whatsoever; it is an article of faith, your faith.
Hm. I honestly don't know what I should answer in order to make a concrete problem more concrete.
Maybe a single example (I know this one can be fixed quick, but there are thousands of articles with the same defect): http://vo.wikipedia.org/wiki/F%C3%A9rin Looks like if the Smeirabot went a bit crazy and forgot to write any real sentence in there. But sure the interwikis from the other wikipedias to this "article" don't undermine the interwiki system at all. Sure...
What you should do is try to understand what the Volapuk Wikipedia, and for that matter similar projects, aims to achieve.
They (no *he*!) want to promote Volapük as a language and attrac new editors with this edit cheating. Thats it. Nothing more. Smeira admitted this. http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Proposals_for_closing_projects%2...
This is also a typical comment of him. Full of cloudy lenghty sentences, wild questioning and other techniques just in order to make the debate diffuse.
Arnomane