On 04/12/2007, Andrew Whitworth wknight8111@gmail.com wrote:
On Dec 4, 2007 4:58 PM, Thomas Dalton thomas.dalton@gmail.com wrote:
The courts have already ruled that what an anonymous contributors posts to an online message board is not the responsibility of the owners of that message board. An online version of the New York Times, if it's open for anonymous submissions, would fall under the same category.
No-one is disputing that. I'm talking about an online newspaper taking submissions from the public, not a public message board. The key difference is that the newspaper selects stories it thinks are good from the submissions.
an online X where anonymous contributors may post materials that are not explicitly moderated or approved prior to public display. In this case, "X" can really be a "online newspaper", "message board", "forum", "newsgroup", etc. Terminology really doesnt make a difference in the method of the post nor the net effect of it.
We are explicitly discussing the case where content *is* moderated and approved, so why are you talking about the opposite? I think everyone on this list is familiar with CDA 230's implications for unmoderated public contributions to websites, since it's brought up at least once a week.