Hello Mathieu! I agree that tracing the full history of a data cite is
important, independent of license. I'm thinking about scalable solutions
for this.
It's definitely not the only factor in reliability; but it does matter who
entered the data (for instance) as one way to estimate the importance of
doublechecking a cited source to confirm that the data is found there.
On Sat, Jul 7, 2018 at 11:59 AM mathieu lovato stumpf guntz <
psychoslave(a)culture-libre.org> wrote:
I agree this is misconception that a copyright license
make any direct
change to data reliability. But attribution requirement does somewhat
indirectly have an impact on it, as it... enforces traceability.
That is I strongly disagree with the following assertion: "a license
that requires BY sucks so hard for data [because] attribution
requirements grow very quickly". To my mind it is equivalent to say that
we will throw away traceability because it is subjectively judged too
large a burden, without providing any start of evidence that it indeed
can't be managed, at least with Wikimedia current ressources.
Now, I don't say traceability is the sole factor one should take into
account in data reliability, but certainly it is one of them.