If you guys have been following the discussions on the Commons Village Pump, I'm sure you're aware of the recent FoP-related DMCA request that came into the WMF.
The situation boils down to this: Commons hosts thousands of images that are non-copyrighted in their source country due to FoP, but whose copyright status within the US is unclear due to the US not having FoP (except for buildings). It is likely that these images are actually copyrighted within the US, although there is a chance that a U.S. court would choose to apply the host country's laws rather than U.S. copyright law in some cases (depending on various technicalities and legal theories). We've known for years that this was the case, put chose to retain the images since no one had ever pushed the issue and no one wanted to delete thousands of images without a solid reason. Well now someone has pushed the issue by sending a DMCA take-down request to the WMF. Although the DMCA request only lists a couple dozen images, it puts all the other images that are in the same situation on very shaky ground. To be more specific, this affects the majority of images tagged with any FoP template. A conservative estimate would be several tens of thousands of photos.
As the US is one of the few countries in the world that lacks Freedom of Panorama, this has prompted many Wikimedians to say it is time for us to start instigating to get this law changed. As the WMF has recently declared that it is not going to be pursuing political advocacy (as part of the "narrowing focus" initiative), it falls to the US chapters to take a leadership role on this issue. I would like to hear other people's thoughts on this issue and especially if they think it would make sense for Wikimedia DC to pursue this further. Does Wikimedia DC have contacts with any lobbying or public interest organizations? Would Wikimedia DC be interested in facilitating a grassroots campaign? If so, what might such a campaign entail? At the very least we could launch a well-worded petition at https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/ and get a few thousand Wikimedians to sign it. Thoughts? Ideas?
Ryan Kaldari