Indeed.  I'm more interested in any personal partially-ordered preferences of members of our group than these ratings. /S 

On Sat, Jul 2, 2022 at 2:00 PM Benjamin Lees <> wrote:
Thanks, Sam.  The rubric says ratings will be assigned based on aggregate scores, but the committee chose to ignore the rubric without even indicating they were doing so, let alone offering a justification.  I think this is a good indication of how much weight we should give these ratings.

On Sat, Jul 2, 2022 at 12:37 PM Samuel Klein <> wrote:
Thanks -- I thought this had been posted to Meta, but it seems it was only emailed to affiliate contacts so far.  
I asked Mervat to update Meta; in the meantime just sharing it here.

Here is the rubric used for analysis. 
- Numbers are averages of the scores given for each category by the [seven] AC members. 
- 'Overall Rating': this seems to be computed automatically from the scores.  Each score is converted to a scale of 1-3 (Bronze, Silver, Gold), then averaged and rounded.  So Gold means roughly "an average score of at least 18.5 in at least two categories", and Bronze would have meant "an avg score of less than 9.5 in at least three categories".

NameUsernameWikimedia BackgroundSought SkillsRegional ExperienceHuman Rights & Underrepresent'nOverall RatingOverall Average
Shani Evenstein SigalovEsh772118.517.519.5Gold19.13
Farah MustaklemFjmustak2016.518.517.5Gold18.13
Kunal MehtaLegoktm2117.251417Silver17.31
Mike PeelMike Peel211718.512.5Gold17.25
Michal BuczyńskiAegis Maelstrom2117.51316Silver16.88
Tobechukwu Precious FridayTochiprecious1913.518.515.5Gold16.63
Joris Darlington QuarshieJoris Darlington Quarshie1614.517.517Silver16.25
Egbe Eugene AgborEugene2331813.251914.5Silver16.19
Lionel SheepmansLionel Scheepmans21131314Silver15.25
Gilbert NdihokubwayoGilbert Ndihokubwayo151217.515Silver14.88
Gina BennettRedwidgeon16111113.5Silver12.88
Abderamane Abakar BrahimAbakar B1210.514.511.5Silver12.13

On Fri, Jul 1, 2022 at 8:35 PM Benjamin Lees <> wrote:
We are supposed to consider the analysis committee's ratings of the candidates for our votes.  Where have those ratings been posted?

On Fri, Jul 1, 2022 at 12:17 PM Samuel Klein <> wrote:
Dear NEWmedians,

The affiliate-selection stage of this year's Trustee elections has started. 

Please respond to Phoebe + I with thoughts + preferences about the current candidate pool.  
I will file a single composite vote for our group next week. 

Wikimedia-boston mailing list --
To unsubscribe send an email to

Samuel Klein          @metasj           w:user:sj          +1 617 529 4266

Samuel Klein          @metasj           w:user:sj          +1 617 529 4266