Thanks, Sam.  The rubric says ratings will be assigned based on aggregate scores, but the committee chose to ignore the rubric without even indicating they were doing so, let alone offering a justification.  I think this is a good indication of how much weight we should give these ratings.

On Sat, Jul 2, 2022 at 12:37 PM Samuel Klein <meta.sj@gmail.com> wrote:

Thanks -- I thought this had been posted to Meta, but it seems it was only emailed to affiliate contacts so far.  

I asked Mervat to update Meta; in the meantime just sharing it here.

Here is the rubric used for analysis. 

- Numbers are averages of the scores given for each category by the [seven] AC members. 
- 'Overall Rating': this seems to be computed automatically from the scores.  Each score is converted to a scale of 1-3 (Bronze, Silver, Gold), then averaged and rounded.  So Gold means roughly "an average score of at least 18.5 in at least two categories", and Bronze would have meant "an avg score of less than 9.5 in at least three categories".

Name	Username	Wikimedia Background	Sought Skills	Regional Experience	Human Rights & Underrepresent'n	Overall Rating	Overall Average
Shani Evenstein Sigalov	Esh77	21	18.5	17.5	19.5	Gold	19.13
Farah Mustaklem	Fjmustak	20	16.5	18.5	17.5	Gold	18.13
Kunal Mehta	Legoktm	21	17.25	14	17	Silver	17.31
Mike Peel	Mike Peel	21	17	18.5	12.5	Gold	17.25
Michal Buczyński	Aegis Maelstrom	21	17.5	13	16	Silver	16.88
Tobechukwu Precious Friday	Tochiprecious	19	13.5	18.5	15.5	Gold	16.63
Joris Darlington Quarshie	Joris Darlington Quarshie	16	14.5	17.5	17	Silver	16.25
Egbe Eugene Agbor	Eugene233	18	13.25	19	14.5	Silver	16.19
Lionel Sheepmans	Lionel Scheepmans	21	13	13	14	Silver	15.25
Gilbert Ndihokubwayo	Gilbert Ndihokubwayo	15	12	17.5	15	Silver	14.88
Gina Bennett	Redwidgeon	16	11	11	13.5	Silver	12.88
Abderamane Abakar Brahim	Abakar B	12	10.5	14.5	11.5	Silver	12.13

On Fri, Jul 1, 2022 at 8:35 PM Benjamin Lees <emufarmers@gmail.com> wrote:

We are supposed to consider the analysis committee's ratings of the candidates for our votes.  Where have those ratings been posted?

On Fri, Jul 1, 2022 at 12:17 PM Samuel Klein <meta.sj@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear NEWmedians,

The affiliate-selection stage of this year's Trustee elections has started. 

Please respond to Phoebe + I with thoughts + preferences about the current candidate pool.  

I will file a single composite vote for our group next week. 

* You can read about the 2022 Board of Trustees candidates, and their answers to the top questions proposed by Affiliate Representatives.

SJ

_______________________________________________
Wikimedia-boston mailing list -- wikimedia-boston@lists.wikimedia.org
To unsubscribe send an email to wikimedia-boston-leave@lists.wikimedia.org

--

Samuel Klein          @metasj           w:user:sj          +1 617 529 4266