On Fri, Aug 12, 2011 at 5:26 AM, Milos Rancic <millosh@gmail.com> wrote:

On Fri, Aug 12, 2011 at 00:15, Thomas Dalton <thomas.dalton@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 12 August 2011 01:10, Иванов Вячеслав <v.ivanov@amikeco.ru> wrote:
>> Latin script may be so bewildering you know.
>> Reading a Hungarian or a Polish name in Latin may require knowing the orthography rules of those languages; and for reading an English name one may need to ask the bearer for the pronunciation :) And probably just IPA would be easier, though, yes, awkward too.
>
> For someone that knows IPA, IPA is definitely best. I don't think
> anyone will argue with that. For everyone else, though, the Latin
> alphabet at least gives us a fighting chance of getting close to the
> right pronunciation. You can always ask "did I say that right?" and
> get corrected. I would ask someone their name and, because it's an
> unfamiliar name to me, I would struggle to make out exactly what they
> said. If I could see it written down and hear it said, I could
> probably get it right.
>
> The other big problem with having names in IPA is that it requires
> attendees to know their name in IPA in order to put it on the name
> badge in the first place. That means it's only going to work when both
> the person whose name it is and the person reading it know IPA. That's
> going to be a pretty small proportion of pairings.

They could rely on the [[<X> phonology]] Wikipedia articles to produce the proper IPA transcription for their name. For some languages, this is quite easy just based on the spelling, with other languages it is more difficult.

One should note though, especially with vowels, that phonemic transcriptions are language dependent. The Polish /ɔ/ sound is closer and more back then the sound /ɔ/ of Hungarian (sometimes transcribed as /ɒ/), and more open compared to the RP /ɔ/.*

As for the intricacies of Latin tranliteration, you might have noticed that longer streets in Israel tend to have slightly differing English names on the streets (sometimes even parts of the streets), Google Maps and guidebooks.**

Best regards,
Bence

* Based on the vowel charts of Wikipedia; individual realisations might vary all over in any of the languages.
** I tried OSM on my phone, but all I got was little squares in place of street names...

Other way is to put cheap chips on the participants' badges with
spoken name and ability to take the information with [the most of]
smartphones.

Some English transcription (not transliteration!) approximation (like
[1]) of the names inside of the parentheses should work well, too.
That's "IPA for those who don't know IPA". It is useful to have, for
example, "Tomash" for Polish "Tomasz" and Hungarian "Tomas".

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Pronunciation_respelling_key

_______________________________________________
Wikimania-l mailing list
Wikimania-l@lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimania-l