Thanks Alex, that was indeed a type of list I was looking for. Ideally, could you make the list with raw url's (as a txt output) - and scale this to all countries (possibly on a per country basis)? 

Thanks!

Lodewijk

2012/6/9 AleXXw <alexxw83@gmail.com>
For Austria:  http://toolserver.org/~alexxw/Denkmalliste/WLM.php?action=Gesamtliste+ohne+Bilder, I'll  check red ones in the next days.

Greets Alex

On Sat, Jun 9, 2012 at 2:17 PM, Lodewijk <lodewijk@effeietsanders.org> wrote:
Hi all,

as you may recall, we have applied for recognition as a guinness world record with the 165.000+ images of 2011. However, to finalize that application, I need some help. We need to determine the final number of submitted picture - and will need two  witnesses who will sign a statement. I'm pretty far with the witnesses - but need some help in making it easy for them to confirm the full number of images. 

I thought the easiest way would be twofold: 
- make sure that the category 'Images from Wiki Loves Monuments 2011' is "clean" - that there are only valid images there. 
- create a list of url's with all submitted images. 

To do that, I'd use the following definition of a valid submission:
- For Switzerland, images submitted in July, August or September 2011 (starting time is in UTC+2, closing time in UTC+0). 
- For all other countries, images submitted in September 2011 (including Hungary, since the images submitted later were not considered for the international contest)
- For all countries, possible delayed bot uploads (we'd need to manually identify those)
- For all countries, the image has to contain the {{Wiki Loves Monuments|country code}} template (I don't think other templates were in use)
- For all images, check whether it is a derivative of an existing image (probably easiest to just list all images that fulfill all other requirements and have a 'other versions' mention - and manually check those)

This should add up to all the images that were considered as a valid submission and could have been nominated for the international contest. Am I missing anything?

It would be great if someone could dig through the category and help clean it. Also, if someone could use a script to generate this list of url's once that is done. That way, for the proof we can both make a screenshot of the category, showing the full number, and count the list of url's and let the witnesses do some random checks on them. 

Best,

Lodewijk




_______________________________________________
Wiki Loves Monuments mailing list
WikiLovesMonuments@lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikilovesmonuments
http://www.wikilovesmonuments.eu