Molu,
<snip/>
If however an admin ceases to be popular within the
community, that
means he has overstayed his welcome and immediately needs to be
kicked out, call it a lynchmob if you will. An admin is a janitor,
not the member of some elite aristocracy and if they perform actions
unpopular to the majority of the community then they are abusing
their powers.
Nonsense. Admins make calls all the time that are recognised by the
community as necessary, but still make one unpopular with certain
subsections nonetheless. RfAs are extraordinarily easy to stack, as
opposers count for more than supporters and the wider community does not
generally take an interest in them. Requests for adminship tend to
involve only a very small subset of the community, who, fortunately, are
usually considered sane (editcountitis notwithstanding); requests for
confirmation will have all the problems of RfA, with the added drawback
of being inhabited by trolls and idiots who are too concerned with
advancing their own agendas to bother learning what admins do and why.
Until RfA can realistically be considered The Voice of the People, it is
not an appropriate or safe mechanism for reconfirming admins. ArbCom
and Jimbo Wales are very well aware of what makes an abusive admin (far
more than users such as, well, *you*), and rest assured, if there's a
problem, they can deal with it far better than a lynch mob of
disgruntled users miffed that they weren't able to turn Wikipedia into
their private playgrounds.
I am not the only person who has noticed that, in your brief time on
this list, you have rarely posted anything that could not be considered
"nonsense". I would like to suggest you spend more time on Wikipedia,
attempting to learn what we're about and how we work, before you try to
instruct the Wikipedia Grannies in advanced egg-sucking procedures. The
views of someone ignorant of Wikipedia procedures can be useful, at
times; fresh eyes, etc., but at others it's damned annoying to see
someone who doesn't know what he's talking about attempt to lecture us.
Please, give it a rest, and fill your head instead of this list.
--
Mark Gallagher
"What? I can't hear you, I've got a banana on my head!"
- Danger Mouse