--- Rick giantsrick13@yahoo.com wrote:
Please see [[User talk:Simplebrain#Please also respond to request from other editors to collaborate]]. User:Simplebrain is attempting to withdraw his edits from the [[Science of Value]] article, and when I suggested that he cannot do so, [[User:Dr Zen]] advised him to institute legal action.
When I read the discussion, it sure sounds like we're dealing with the original founder of the modern study of "Science of Value". As such, isn't this page either vanity or original research? Isn't it therefore a ripe candidate for VFD?
Aside from RickK's addition of {{cleanup}} and {{wikify}}, only user:Hu and user:Gene Ward Smith have made any changes to Simplebrain's work. Hu made a single effort to remove POV while retaining the essence of the entry. Gene Ward Smith's edits amount to a negative critique of the concept.
Essentially, what we have is a simple "he said, she said" between someone's original research and a single critic.
Perhaps we can work for a true NPOV presentation of the concepts, but can't we just do everyone a favor and delete the current article?
-Rich Holton (en.wikipedia:user:rholton)
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? The all-new My Yahoo! - What will yours do? http://my.yahoo.com